Seth Vikas, Upadhyaya Prerna, Ahmad Mushtaq, Kumar Virendra
Department of Pharmacology, Mahatma Gandhi Medical College, Jaipur, India.
Department of Anatomy, Mahatma Gandhi Medical College, Jaipur, India.
EXCLI J. 2010 Aug 25;9:96-101. eCollection 2010.
The aim of the study was to assess the impact of three common lecture delivery methods viz. the lectures using chalkboard, the lectures using PowerPoint presentations and the lectures utilizing transparencies with an overhead projector. By filling in a questionnaire, the second year MBBS students were asked to assess the impact of three pharmacology lectures given by three different methods of lecture delivery. Also after each lecture an objective test was given to compare the impact of the lecture delivered by different methods. The results of the study show that as per the subjective assessment of the lectures, students preferred PowerPoint teaching the most. As far as the students' performance is concerned the impact of traditional Chalkboard and PowerPoint teaching was much more than the lectures using transparency and overhead projector (OHP).
该研究的目的是评估三种常见授课方式的影响,即使用黑板的讲座、使用PowerPoint演示文稿的讲座以及使用投影仪播放透明胶片的讲座。通过填写问卷,要求医学学士二年级学生评估由三种不同授课方式进行的三次药理学讲座的影响。此外,在每次讲座后都进行了客观测试,以比较不同授课方式的讲座效果。研究结果表明,根据对讲座的主观评估,学生最喜欢PowerPoint教学。就学生的表现而言,传统黑板教学和PowerPoint教学的效果远高于使用透明胶片和投影仪的讲座。