Adelaide Nursing School, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA, Australia.
Department of Surgical Sciences, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden.
J Clin Nurs. 2018 Jun;27(11-12):2285-2299. doi: 10.1111/jocn.14247. Epub 2018 Feb 12.
To generate a standardised definition for fundamental care and identify the discrete elements that constitute such care.
There is poor conceptual clarity surrounding fundamental care. The Fundamentals of Care Framework aims to overcome this problem by outlining three core dimensions underpinning such care. Implementing the Framework requires a standardised definition for fundamental care that reflects the Framework's conceptual understanding, as well as agreement on the elements that comprise such care (i.e., patient needs, such as nutrition, and nurse actions, such as empathy). This study sought to achieve this consensus.
Modified Delphi study.
Three phases: (i) engaging stakeholders via an interactive workshop; (ii) using workshop findings to develop a preliminary definition for, and identify the discrete elements that constitute, fundamental care; and (iii) gaining consensus on the definition and elements via a two-round Delphi approach (Round 1 n = 38; Round 2 n = 28).
Delphi participants perceived both the definition and elements generated from the workshop as comprehensive, but beyond the scope of fundamental care. Participants questioned whether the definition should focus on patient needs and nurse actions, or more broadly on how fundamental care should be delivered (e.g., through a trusting nurse-patient relationship), and the outcomes of this care delivery. There were also mixed opinions whether the definition should be nursing specific.
This study has initiated crucial dialogue around how fundamental care is conceptualised and defined. Future work should focus on further refinements of the definition and elements with a larger, international group of practising nurses and service users.
The definition and elements, through ongoing refinement, will contribute to a robust evidence base that will underpin policy development and the systematic and effective teaching, delivery, measurement and evaluation of fundamental care.
生成基本护理的标准化定义,并确定构成此类护理的离散元素。
基本护理的概念理解不清楚。护理基础框架旨在通过概述支撑此类护理的三个核心维度来解决这个问题。实施该框架需要一个反映框架概念理解的基本护理标准化定义,以及对构成此类护理的元素(即患者需求,如营养,和护士行为,如同理心)达成一致。这项研究旨在达成共识。
改良 Delphi 研究。
三个阶段:(一)通过互动研讨会让利益相关者参与;(二)利用研讨会的结果为基本护理制定初步定义,并确定构成基本护理的离散元素;(三)通过两轮 Delphi 方法(第一轮 n=38;第二轮 n=28)就定义和元素达成共识。
Delphi 参与者认为研讨会生成的定义和元素都很全面,但超出了基本护理的范围。参与者质疑定义是否应该关注患者需求和护士行为,或者更广泛地关注基本护理应该如何提供(例如,通过信任的护患关系),以及这种护理提供的结果。对于定义是否应该针对护理特定,也存在不同意见。
本研究已经就基本护理的概念化和定义展开了重要的讨论。未来的工作应该集中在更大的、国际范围内的执业护士和服务用户群体中,进一步完善定义和元素。
通过不断完善,定义和元素将有助于建立一个稳健的证据基础,为政策制定以及基本护理的系统和有效教学、提供、衡量和评估提供支持。