University of Nottingham, UK.
Coventry University, UK.
J Interpers Violence. 2020 Jul;35(13-14):2399-2421. doi: 10.1177/0886260517702489. Epub 2017 Apr 13.
This study explores modeling crime-scene characteristics of juvenile homicide in the French-speaking part of Belgium. Multidimensional scaling analysis was carried out on crime-scene characteristics derived from the court files of 67 individuals under 22 years old, who had been charged with murder or attempted murder (1995-2009). Three thematic regions (Expressive: multiple offenders; Instrumental: theft; Instrumental: sex/forensic awareness) distinguished types of aggression displayed during the offense. These themes reaffirm that the expressive-instrumental differentiation found in general homicide studies is valuable when attempting to discriminate juvenile homicides. The proposed framework was found useful to classify the offenses, as 84% of homicides were assigned to a dominant theme. Additionally, associations between crime-scene characteristics and offenders' characteristics were analyzed, but no associations were found, therefore failing to provide empirical support for the homology assumption. Cultural comparisons, as well as the influence of age on the thematic structure are discussed.
本研究探讨了比利时法语区青少年杀人案件现场特征的建模。对 67 名 22 岁以下的犯罪者的法庭记录中的案件现场特征进行了多维标度分析,这些犯罪者被控谋杀或谋杀未遂(1995-2009 年)。三个主题区域(表现型:多个犯罪者;工具型:盗窃;工具型:性/法医意识)区分了犯罪过程中表现出的不同类型的攻击。这些主题再次证实,在一般杀人研究中发现的表现-工具分化在试图区分青少年杀人案时是有价值的。所提出的框架被发现有助于对犯罪进行分类,因为 84%的杀人案被归为一个主要主题。此外,还分析了案件现场特征与犯罪者特征之间的关联,但未发现关联,因此未能为同源假设提供经验支持。讨论了文化比较以及年龄对主题结构的影响。