College of Veterinary Medicine, Konkuk University, Gwangjin-gu, Seoul, South Korea.
Sooje Animal Hospital, Dongducheon-si, Gyeonggi-do, Korea.
Transbound Emerg Dis. 2018 Jun;65(3):735-745. doi: 10.1111/tbed.12798. Epub 2018 Jan 10.
Modified live vaccines (MLVs) based on genotype 1 strains, particularly C-strain, have been used to prevent and control classical swine fever virus (CSFV) worldwide. Nevertheless, a shift in the predominant CSFV strains circulating in the field from genotype 1 or 3 to genotype 2 is seen. Genotype 2 is genetically distant from the vaccine strains and was recently reported during outbreaks after vaccine failure; this has raised concerns that vaccination has influenced viral evolution. In Korea in 2016, there was an unexpected CSF outbreak in a MLV-vaccinated commercial pig herd. The causative CSFV strain was genetically distinct from previously isolated Korean strains but similar to recent Chinese strains exhibiting enhanced capacity to escape neutralization; this suggests the need for global cooperative research on the evolution of CSFV. We analysed global E2 sequences, using bioinformatics tools, revealing the evolutionary pathways of CSFV. Classical swine fever virus genotypes 1 and 2 experienced different degrees and patterns of evolutionary growth. Whereas genotype 1 stayed relatively conserved over time, the genetic diversity of genotype 2 has progressively expanded, with few fluctuations. It was determined that genotype 2 evolved under lower immune pressures and at a higher evolutionary rate than genotype 1. Further, several selected codons, under diversifying selection in genotype 1 but under purifying selection in genotype 2, correspond to antigenic determinants, which could lead to evasion of vaccine-induced immunity. Our findings provide evidence that evolutionary changes in CSFV are the result of the disproportionate usage of the CSF MLVs in endemic areas; this underscores the need to develop mitigation strategies to minimize the substantial risk associated with the emergence of vaccine-escaping mutants.
基于 1 型(尤其是 C 型)毒株的弱毒活疫苗已被广泛用于预防和控制经典猪瘟病毒(Classical swine fever virus,CSFV)。然而,目前在流行地区,CSFV 的主要流行株已从 1 型或 3 型转变为 2 型。2 型与疫苗株的亲缘关系较远,且最近在疫苗失败后的暴发中被报道;这引发了人们对疫苗接种是否影响病毒进化的担忧。2016 年韩国的一次 MLV 疫苗接种商业猪群中出现了意外的 CSF 暴发。引起 CSF 的 CSFV 株与之前分离的韩国株在基因上有明显不同,但与最近具有更强逃逸中和能力的中国株相似;这表明需要在全球范围内合作研究 CSFV 的进化。我们利用生物信息学工具分析了全球 E2 序列,揭示了 CSFV 的进化途径。CSFV 的 1 型和 2 型经历了不同程度和模式的进化增长。虽然 1 型在一段时间内保持相对保守,但 2 型的遗传多样性却在不断扩大,且波动较少。结果表明,2 型在较低的免疫压力下以比 1 型更高的进化速度进化。此外,在 1 型中处于多样化选择下而在 2 型中处于纯化选择下的几个选择密码子,对应于抗原决定簇,这可能导致疫苗诱导的免疫逃逸。我们的研究结果表明,CSFV 的进化变化是由于在流行地区过度使用 CSF MLV 所致;这凸显了需要制定缓解策略,以最大程度地降低与疫苗逃逸突变体出现相关的巨大风险。