Hederlingova J, Redman Ch W, Zahumensky J
Bratisl Lek Listy. 2017;118(12):732-735. doi: 10.4149/BLL_2017_138.
Follow-up of women with biopsy-confirmed CIN2+ who were either treated immediately with LLETZ or managed conservatively to determine the rates of patients back on routine screening programme after a median of three years in two groups.
In this retrospective study, 310 patients were involved who had undergone biopsy with result of CIN2+ between January 2011 and December 2014. Depending on the management, i.e. based on whether cytology and colposcopy follow-up or immediate treatment were performed, they were divided in two groups. Then the number of patients back on routine screening up to 15/2/2016 as well as the results of last cytology were compared within both groups.
A total of 310 women at average age of 30 years met the inclusion criteria. Of them, 230 (74 %) had immediate treatment whereas 80 (26 %) were managed conservatively. There were no statistically significant demographic differences between the two groups. The mean time of follow up was 1.091 days (2.98 years). The patients managed conservatively required more follow-up visits at colposcopy clinic (p<0.001). The last documented cytology in the immediate treatment group was negative in 93 % and low-grade/borderline in 7 % of patients, while in the conservative management group, it was negative in 84 %, low-grade/borderline in 15 % and high-grade in 1 % of patients (p = 0.015). Overall, the proportions of patients who are back on routine screening recall are 96 % and 87.5 % for the immediate treatment and conservatively managed groups, respectively (p=0.022).
The conservative management of high-grade CIN with cytology and colposcopic follow up is an OPTION in selected group of patients, but it cannot be routinely recommended (Tab. 2, Ref. 20).
对活检确诊为CIN2+的女性进行随访,这些女性要么立即接受大环状电切除术(LLETZ)治疗,要么进行保守处理,以确定两组患者在中位时间三年后重新回到常规筛查项目的比例。
在这项回顾性研究中,纳入了2011年1月至2014年12月间活检结果为CIN2+的310例患者。根据处理方式,即基于是否进行细胞学和阴道镜随访或立即治疗,将她们分为两组。然后比较两组中截至2016年2月15日重新回到常规筛查的患者数量以及最后一次细胞学检查结果。
共有310名平均年龄为30岁的女性符合纳入标准。其中,230例(74%)立即接受了治疗,而80例(26%)接受了保守处理。两组之间在人口统计学方面没有统计学上的显著差异。平均随访时间为1091天(2.98年)。接受保守处理的患者需要在阴道镜诊所进行更多的随访(p<0.001)。立即治疗组中最后记录的细胞学检查结果,93%的患者为阴性,7%为低级别/临界性病变;而在保守处理组中,84%的患者为阴性,15%为低级别/临界性病变,1%为高级别病变(p = 0.015)。总体而言,立即治疗组和保守处理组重新回到常规筛查召回的患者比例分别为96%和87.5%(p=0.022)。
对高级别CIN进行细胞学和阴道镜随访的保守处理是部分选定患者的一种选择,但不能常规推荐(表2,参考文献20)。