Carvalho Maria Pais de, Pinto Daniela, Gorayeb Melissa, Jacinto Jorge
a Serviço de Medicina Física e de Reabilitação , Centro Hospitalar Tondela Viseu , Viseu , Portugal.
b Serviço de Reabilitação de Adultos 3 , Centro de Medicina de Reabilitação de Alcoitão , Alcoitão , Portugal.
Top Stroke Rehabil. 2018 Apr;25(3):194-202. doi: 10.1080/10749357.2017.1420009. Epub 2018 Jan 11.
Background Botulinum toxin type-A (BoNTA) is a recognized treatment for upper limb spasticity (ULS) after stroke, but there aren't many studies analyzing its effect in shoulder muscles. Objective To evaluate the efficacy of BoNTA injections for ULS, when shoulder muscles are included. Methods A cross-sectional study. Data from clinical forms of outpatients, treated at a Rehabilitation Center (2001-2016). Analyzes: goals of treatment; demographic characteristics/goal; treatment success, using Goal Attainment Scaling. Results Eighty-six stroke-patients, submitted to 547 BoNTA treatment sessions. The most injected shoulder muscles were subscapularis (SC) 35%, pectoralis major (PM) 31%, deltoideus 14%. The most selected goals for treatment were: involuntary movements (IM) 33%, pain/discomfort (PD) 26%, and mobility (MOB) 18%. Patients achieved or overachieved the IM goal in 76%, PD in 78%, and MOB in 79%. Patients with IM goal were younger (p < 0.01), than those setting other goal types; PD patients, were older (p < 0.019), treated half a year earlier (p < 0.01), and had more spasticity (MAS ≠ 0.15); MOB patients were younger (p = 0.04) and less spastic (MAS ≠ 0.12). Achieving PD goal impacted positively in improving MOB (p = 0.042) and passive function (p = 0.018). Conclusion When treating ULS, including shoulder muscles, the most frequent goals were IM, PD e MOB. The most injected muscles were SC and PM. The treatment was successful in a large percentage of cases. Achieving the PD goal was associated with greater success at other goals of treatment. BoNTA demonstrated a positive effect in controlling symptoms and improving function.
A型肉毒毒素(BoNTA)是一种公认的治疗中风后上肢痉挛(ULS)的方法,但分析其对肩部肌肉影响的研究并不多。目的:评估在纳入肩部肌肉时,BoNTA注射治疗ULS的疗效。方法:一项横断面研究。数据来自于一家康复中心(2001 - 2016年)门诊患者的临床表格。分析内容包括:治疗目标;人口统计学特征/目标;使用目标达成量表评估治疗成功率。结果:86例中风患者接受了547次BoNTA治疗。注射最多的肩部肌肉是肩胛下肌(SC),占35%,胸大肌(PM)占31%,三角肌占14%。最常选择的治疗目标是:不自主运动(IM)占33%,疼痛/不适(PD)占26%,活动度(MOB)占18%。患者实现或超额实现IM目标的比例为76%,PD目标为78%,MOB目标为79%。设定IM目标的患者比设定其他目标类型的患者更年轻(p < 0.01);设定PD目标的患者年龄更大(p < 0.019),治疗时间早半年(p < 0.01),且痉挛程度更高(改良Ashworth量表评分≠0.15);设定MOB目标的患者更年轻(p = 0.04),痉挛程度更低(改良Ashworth量表评分≠0.12)。实现PD目标对改善MOB(p = 0.042)和被动功能(p = 0.018)有积极影响。结论:在治疗包括肩部肌肉的ULS时,最常见的目标是IM、PD和MOB。注射最多的肌肉是SC和PM。该治疗在很大比例的病例中取得了成功。实现PD目标与在其他治疗目标上取得更大成功相关。BoNTA在控制症状和改善功能方面显示出积极作用。