Robinson Karen, Garnier-Villarreal Mauricio, Hanson Lisa
College of Nursing, Marquette University, Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
J Perinat Neonatal Nurs. 2018 Apr/Jun;32(2):116-126. doi: 10.1097/JPN.0000000000000307.
While breastfeeding initiation rates for African American mothers are low, an innovative model of group prenatal care, CenteringPregnancy, holds promise to increase breastfeeding rates. The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to examine the effects of CenteringPregnancy versus individual prenatal care on breastfeeding initiation among African American mothers. Using a systematic approach and PRISMA guidelines, 4 electronic databases were used to search the literature. English-language studies, comparing CenteringPregnancy and individual prenatal care, including African American participants, and specifying breastfeeding initiation as an outcome were screened for inclusion. Study strength and quality were assessed and 7 studies were systematically reviewed and meta-analyzed. Participation in CenteringPregnancy increased the probability of breastfeeding initiation by 53% (95% confidence interval = 29%-81%) (n = 8047). A subgroup analysis of breastfeeding initiation among only African American participants was performed on 4 studies where data were available. Participation in CenteringPregnancy increased the probability of breastfeeding initiation by 71% (95% confidence interval = 27%-131%) (n = 1458) for African American participants. CenteringPregnancy is an effective intervention to increase breastfeeding initiation for participants, especially for African Americans. To close the racial gap in breastfeeding initiation, high-quality research providing specific outcomes for African American participants in CenteringPregnancy are needed.
尽管非裔美国母亲的母乳喂养启动率较低,但一种创新的团体产前护理模式——“孕期集中护理”(CenteringPregnancy)有望提高母乳喂养率。本系统评价和荟萃分析的目的是研究“孕期集中护理”与个体产前护理对非裔美国母亲母乳喂养启动的影响。采用系统方法和PRISMA指南,使用4个电子数据库检索文献。筛选纳入的研究为英文研究,比较“孕期集中护理”和个体产前护理,包括非裔美国参与者,并将母乳喂养启动作为一项结果指标。评估研究的强度和质量,并对7项研究进行系统评价和荟萃分析。参与“孕期集中护理”使母乳喂养启动的概率提高了53%(95%置信区间=29%-81%)(n = 8047)。对4项有可用数据的研究进行了仅针对非裔美国参与者母乳喂养启动情况的亚组分析。对于非裔美国参与者,参与“孕期集中护理”使母乳喂养启动的概率提高了71%(95%置信区间=27%-131%)(n = 1458)。“孕期集中护理”是一种有效的干预措施,可提高参与者尤其是非裔美国人的母乳喂养启动率。为了缩小母乳喂养启动方面的种族差距,需要开展高质量研究,提供非裔美国参与者在“孕期集中护理”中的具体结果。