Soejono Czeresna Heriawan, Padmawati Retna S, Utarini Adi
Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Medicine Universitas Indonesia - Cipto Mangunkusumo Hospital, Jakarta, Indonesia..
Acta Med Indones. 2017 Oct;49(4):336-342.
the National Health Insurance (NIH/JKN) has been enacted since January 2014. Various outcomes of geriatric patient care, such as improved functional status and quality of life have not been evaluated. Prolonged hospitalization and re-hospitalization are potentially affecting the efficiency care of this vulnarable group. This study aimed to identify the differences of functional status improvement, quality of life improvement, length of stay, and hospitalization of geriatric patients admitted to CMH between prior to and after NHI implementation.
a cohort study with historical control was conducted among geriatric patients admitted to Acute Geriatric Ward CMH Hospital on two periods of time: January-December 2013 (pre-NHI implementation) and June 2014-May 2015 (after NHI implementation). Patients who died within 24 hours of hospital admission, those with APPACHE II score >24, advance stage cancer, transfer to other wards before they were discharged or have incomplete record were excluded from the study. Data on demographical and clinical characteristics, functional status, quality of life, length of stay, and re-hospitalization were taken from patient's medical record. The differences of studied outcomes were analyzed using t-test or Mann-Whitney test.
there were 102 subjects in pre-NHI and 135 subjects in NHI groups included in the study. Median lengths of stay were not different between two groups (12.5 days in pre-NHI and 10 days in NHI groups, p=0.087), although the proportion of patients with in-hospital stay less than 14 days was higher in NHI group. The difference of functional status of discharged patients in pre-NHI and NHI groups were 3 and 3 (p=0.149) respectively, whereas for health-related quality of life, although NHI group in the beginning showed a lower quality of life compared to the pre-NHI (0.163 [0.480] vs. 0.243 [0.550]; p=0.012). However, after incorporating comprehensive geriatric assessment (CGA) the quality of life improved significantly by the end of in-hospital care in both groups. Re-hospitalization incidence in NHI group was lower compared to pre-NHI (7 [5.2%] vs. 13 [12.7%]; p=0.038).
our study shows that there was no significant difference regarding length of stay, functional status, and health-related quality of life between prior to and after national health insurance implementation on admitted geriatric patients. Rehospitalization incidence showed better results in NHI group and hence NHI implementation is favored.
国家健康保险(NIH/JKN)自2014年1月起实施。老年患者护理的各种结果,如功能状态和生活质量的改善尚未得到评估。长期住院和再次住院可能会影响这个弱势群体的护理效率。本研究旨在确定国家健康保险实施前后,入住CMH的老年患者在功能状态改善、生活质量改善、住院时间和住院情况方面的差异。
对入住CMH医院急性老年病房的老年患者进行了一项有历史对照的队列研究,研究分为两个时间段:2013年1月至12月(国家健康保险实施前)和2014年6月至2015年5月(国家健康保险实施后)。入院后24小时内死亡的患者、急性生理与慢性健康状况评分系统(APACHE II)得分>24的患者、晚期癌症患者、出院前转至其他病房或记录不完整的患者被排除在研究之外。人口统计学和临床特征、功能状态、生活质量、住院时间和再次住院的数据取自患者的病历。使用t检验或曼-惠特尼检验分析研究结果的差异。
研究纳入了国家健康保险实施前的102名受试者和国家健康保险组的135名受试者。两组的中位住院时间没有差异(国家健康保险实施前为12.5天,国家健康保险组为10天,p=0.087),尽管国家健康保险组住院时间少于14天的患者比例更高。国家健康保险实施前和国家健康保险组出院患者的功能状态差异分别为3和3(p=0.149),而对于与健康相关的生活质量,尽管国家健康保险组一开始的生活质量低于国家健康保险实施前(0.163[0.480]对0.243[0.550];p=0.012)。然而,在纳入综合老年评估(CGA)后,两组患者在住院治疗结束时生活质量均显著改善。国家健康保险组的再次住院发生率低于国家健康保险实施前(7[5.2%]对13[12.7%];p=0.038)。
我们的研究表明,国家健康保险实施前后,老年住院患者的住院时间、功能状态和与健康相关的生活质量没有显著差异。再次住院发生率在国家健康保险组有更好的结果,因此国家健康保险的实施是有利的。