Center for Suicide Research, Troy, MI, and Wayne State University, Detroit, MI, USA.
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Suicide Life Threat Behav. 2019 Apr;49(2):371-381. doi: 10.1111/sltb.12435. Epub 2018 Jan 25.
Research on religion as a protective factor has been marked by four recurrent limitations: (1) an overemphasis on the United States, a nation where religiosity is relatively high; (2) a neglect of highly secularized zones of the world, where religiousness may be too weak to affect suicide; (3) restriction of religiousness to religious affiliation, a construct which may miss capturing other dimensions of religiousness such as the importance of religion in one's life; and (4) an overwhelming use of the nation as a unit of analysis, which masks variation in religiousness within nations. The present article addresses these limitations by performing a cross-national test of the following hypothesis: The greater the strength of subjective religiousness, the lower the suicide rate, using small units of analysis for a secularized area of the world. All data refer to 162 regions within 22 European nations. Data were extracted from two large databases, EUROSTAT and the European Social Surveys (ESS Round 4), and merged using NUTS-2 (Nomenclature of Statistical Territorial Units) regions as the unit of analysis. Controls are incorporated for level of economic development, education, and measures of economic strain. The results of a multiple regression analysis demonstrated that controlling for the other constructs in the model, religiousness is associated with lower suicide rates, confirming the hypothesis. Even in secularized European nations, where there is a relatively weak moral community to reinforce religion, religiousness acts as a protective factor against suicide. Future work is needed to explore the relationship in other culture zones of the world.
(1)过分强调美国,一个宗教信仰相对较高的国家;(2)忽视了世界上高度世俗化的地区,在这些地区,宗教信仰可能太弱,无法影响自杀率;(3)将宗教信仰限制在宗教归属上,这种构建可能会错过捕捉宗教信仰的其他维度,例如宗教在一个人生活中的重要性;(4)压倒性地使用国家作为分析单位,这掩盖了国家内部宗教信仰的差异。本文通过对以下假设进行跨国检验来解决这些局限性:主观宗教信仰越强,自杀率越低,使用世界上世俗化地区的小单位进行分析。所有数据均指 22 个欧洲国家的 162 个地区。数据取自两个大型数据库,即 EUROSTAT 和欧洲社会调查(第四轮),并使用 NUTS-2(统计地域单位命名法)地区作为分析单位进行合并。纳入了经济发展水平、教育水平和经济压力衡量指标的控制变量。多元回归分析的结果表明,在控制模型中的其他结构变量后,宗教信仰与较低的自杀率相关,证实了这一假设。即使在宗教信仰相对较弱的欧洲世俗化国家,宗教信仰也作为一种保护因素,起到了预防自杀的作用。未来需要进一步研究世界其他文化区域的关系。