Kunte R, Basannar D, Chatterjee K, Agarwal P K, Prasad L, Dubey P, Ravi P R
Professor & Head, Department of Community Medicine, Armed Forces Medical College, Pune 411040, India.
Scientist F, Dept of Community Medicine, Armed Forces Medical College, Pune 411040, India.
Med J Armed Forces India. 2017 Oct;73(4):356-362. doi: 10.1016/j.mjafi.2017.09.018. Epub 2017 Nov 15.
Most studies on stress fractures in India have been carried out among recruits as against officer trainees and limited to males. With the continuous induction of women in the Armed Forces, it was decided to carry out a study among officer trainees of the three services and compare the epidemiology among genders.
A prospective study was carried out in 2011-2012 at Training Institutes of the three services where male and female cadets train together. Baseline data was collected for all trainees who joined the academy during the study period. All cadets were followed up for development of stress fractures for which details were taken. Additional information was taken from the Training Institute.
A total of 3220 cadets (2612 male and 608 female cadets) were included in the study. Overall 276 cadets were observed to have stress fractures during training - making an incidence of 6.9% for male cadets and 15.8% for female cadets. Females were found to have a significantly higher incidence of stress fractures. Further the distribution and onset of stress fractures in females was observed to be distinct from males.
The significant gender differential observed in the study indicates differential role of intrinsic and extrinsic risk factors in the causation of stress fractures among male and female. Special consideration needs to be given to these while planning and implementing measures for prevention. Further studies may be carried out on subject and on the effect of interventions in stress fracture prevention.
印度大多数关于应力性骨折的研究是针对新兵而非军官学员进行的,且仅限于男性。随着女性不断加入武装部队,决定对三军军官学员开展一项研究,并比较不同性别的流行病学情况。
2011年至2012年在三军培训机构开展了一项前瞻性研究,男女学员共同在此训练。收集了研究期间进入该学院的所有学员的基线数据。对所有学员进行随访,记录应力性骨折的发生情况及相关细节。还从培训机构获取了其他信息。
共有3220名学员(2612名男学员和608名女学员)纳入研究。训练期间共观察到276名学员发生应力性骨折,男学员发生率为6.9%,女学员为15.8%。发现女性应力性骨折发生率显著更高。此外,观察到女性应力性骨折的分布和发病情况与男性不同。
本研究中观察到的显著性别差异表明,内在和外在风险因素在男女应力性骨折病因中起不同作用。在规划和实施预防措施时需对此予以特别考虑。可针对该主题以及预防应力性骨折干预措施的效果开展进一步研究。