Paparella Tanya, Freeman Stephanny F N
Department of Child Psychiatry and Biobehavioral Sciences, University of California Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Pediatric Health Med Ther. 2015 May 19;6:65-78. doi: 10.2147/PHMT.S41921. eCollection 2015.
We provide an overview of studies in the past 10 years (2004-2014) that have aimed to improve joint attention (JA) in young children at risk for, or with, autism spectrum disorder. Thirteen randomized controlled trial (RCT) interventions were found, which received particular focus. Three studies used intervention methods with a developmental orientation and focused on caregiver-mediated methods. Others used combined developmental and behavioral approaches and delivered intervention via trained interventionists, caregivers, and teachers. Interventions ranged widely in density, both with respect to the amount of intervention delivered weekly and the total duration of intervention. Fourteen single-subject research design (SSRD) studies and one quasi-experimental pre-post design study were also included. Notably absent in the RCTs were studies using only behavioral methods, while behavioral methods dominated in the SSRDs. The outcomes of the RCTs using combined behavioral and developmental methods generally demonstrate short-term social communication gains. While some studies demonstrated long-term maintenance and positive outcomes in related areas such as language, many did not. The mixed results for language outcomes indicate a need for further investigation. In addition, future studies should further examine participants' developmental readiness and intervention dose in relation to outcome, as well as aim to isolate active ingredients of interventions.
我们概述了过去10年(2004 - 2014年)旨在改善有自闭症谱系障碍风险或患有自闭症谱系障碍的幼儿的共同注意(JA)的研究。我们找到了13项随机对照试验(RCT)干预措施,并对其给予了特别关注。三项研究采用了具有发展导向的干预方法,并侧重于照料者介导的方法。其他研究则采用了发展与行为相结合的方法,并通过受过培训的干预人员、照料者和教师进行干预。干预在强度上差异很大,这体现在每周提供的干预量以及干预的总时长方面。我们还纳入了14项单被试研究设计(SSRD)研究和一项准实验前后设计研究。值得注意的是,随机对照试验中没有仅使用行为方法的研究,而行为方法在单被试研究设计中占主导地位。使用行为与发展相结合方法的随机对照试验结果总体上显示出短期社交沟通方面的改善。虽然一些研究在语言等相关领域显示出长期维持效果和积极成果,但许多研究并非如此。语言结果的混合情况表明有必要进一步研究。此外,未来的研究应进一步考察参与者的发展准备情况和与结果相关的干预剂量,以及旨在分离出干预的有效成分。