Honegger D, Holz J, Baume L J
SSO Schweiz Monatsschr Zahnheilkd. 1979 Oct;89(10):1020-41.
Of 123 teeth treated by direct pulp capping 110 could be rechecked clinically and radiographically after periods of 1 1/2 to 7 years, 4 on the average. In 25 cases a change in endodontic treatment has been recorded on the files: In 18 cases biopulpectomy was performed for symptomatic (pain) reasons considered as failure of the capping treatment; in 5 cases biopulpectomy was indicated for periodontal and prosthetic reasons (not considered as failure); in 5 cases of the 110 rechecked necrosis and periapical involvement was diagnosed. The rate of failure thus was 22 cases or 17%. This relatively high ratio of unfavorable results (Tab. VII) is in part due to lack of operative skill of the students while progressing tooth morbidity statistically established in the Genevan population also was taken into account. Advancing tooth ages according to graph figure 6 in accordance with other recent surveys were found to constitute no impediment for direct pulp capping. The success of this endodontic treatment is best ascertained by observing a strict selection of the case and the observance of an exacting operative procedure, namely: - Only accidentally exposed pulps without symptoms of previous spontaneous pain (Category I) are liable to successful conservation by direct pulp capping using calcium hydroxide. Previously painful pulps (Category II) according to Table VIII are either indirectly capped using corticosteroids particularly in young teeth or after exposure subject to coronal or radicular pulpotomy (Category III). Rigorous aseptical procedure and lasting hermetical sealing of the calcium hydroxide pulp dressing are additional prerequisites for success.
在接受直接盖髓治疗的123颗牙齿中,110颗在1年半至7年(平均4年)后可进行临床和影像学复查。病历记录显示有25例进行了牙髓治疗的变更:18例因出现症状(疼痛),认为盖髓治疗失败而进行了牙髓部分切除;5例因牙周和修复原因进行了牙髓部分切除(不视为失败);在110颗接受复查的牙齿中,有5例被诊断为牙髓坏死和根尖周病变。因此,失败率为22例,即17%。这种相对较高的不良结果比例(表VII)部分是由于学生操作技能不足,同时也考虑到了日内瓦人群中统计学确定的牙齿发病率上升情况。根据图6以及其他近期调查,牙齿年龄增长并未对直接盖髓构成障碍。这种牙髓治疗的成功最好通过严格选择病例和遵守严格的操作程序来确定,即:- 只有意外暴露且无先前自发疼痛症状的牙髓(I类),使用氢氧化钙进行直接盖髓才有成功保存的可能。根据表VIII,先前有疼痛的牙髓(II类),特别是在年轻牙齿中,可使用皮质类固醇进行间接盖髓,或在暴露后进行冠髓或根髓切断术(III类)。严格的无菌操作和氢氧化钙牙髓敷料的持久密封是成功的额外前提条件。