Whitaker Lydia, Brown Stephen L, Young Bridget, Fereday Richard, Coyne Sarah M, Qualter Pamela
Department of Psychological Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, United Kingdom.
College of Family, Home and Social Sciences, Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2018 Feb 6;13(2):e0191269. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0191269. eCollection 2018.
Laboratory studies of alcohol-inexperienced adolescents show that aggression can be primed by alcohol-related stimuli, suggesting that alcohol-related aggression is partly socially learned. Script theory proposes that alcohol-related aggression 'scripts' for social behaviors are culturally-available and learned by individuals. The purpose of the study was to understand the content and origins of alcohol-related aggression scripts learned by adolescents. This qualitative focus group study of 40 adolescents (ages 14-16 years) examined alcohol-related aggression scripts. Participants believed aggression and severe injury to be pervasive when young people drink. Viewed through a biological lens, participants described aggression as an 'instinctive' and 'hard-wired' male trait facilitated by intoxication. As such, alcohol-related aggression was not seen as intended or personally controllable and participants did not see it in moral terms. Females were largely viewed as either bystanders of inter-male aggression or potential victims of male sexual aggression. Participants attributed their views on the frequency and nature of alcohol-related aggression to current affairs and reality television, which they felt portrayed a reality of which they had little experience. The origins of the explicitly biological frameworks that participants used seemed to lie in pre-existing beliefs about the nature of gender differences. Perceptions of the pervasiveness of male alcohol-related aggression, and the consequent failure to view alcohol-related aggression in moral terms, could dispose some young people to alcohol-related aggression. Interventions could target (1) the beliefs that alcohol-related aggression is pervasive and uncontrollable in males, and (2) participants' dysfunctional views of masculinity that underpin those beliefs.
对缺乏饮酒经验的青少年进行的实验室研究表明,与酒精相关的刺激会引发攻击行为,这表明与酒精相关的攻击行为部分是通过社会学习获得的。脚本理论提出,社会行为中与酒精相关的攻击“脚本”在文化中是存在的,并且个体可以习得。本研究的目的是了解青少年习得的与酒精相关的攻击脚本的内容和来源。这项对40名青少年(年龄在14至16岁之间)进行的定性焦点小组研究,考察了与酒精相关的攻击脚本。参与者认为,年轻人饮酒时,攻击行为和严重伤害很普遍。从生物学角度来看,参与者将攻击行为描述为一种由醉酒助长的“本能”且“与生俱来”的男性特质。因此,与酒精相关的攻击行为不被视为有意为之或个人可以控制的,参与者也没有从道德层面看待它。女性在很大程度上被视为男性间攻击行为的旁观者或男性性攻击行为的潜在受害者。参与者将他们对与酒精相关攻击行为的频率和性质的看法归因于时事和真人秀节目,他们觉得这些节目描绘了一个他们几乎没有体验过的现实。参与者所使用的明确的生物学框架的来源似乎在于他们先前对性别差异本质的信念。对男性与酒精相关攻击行为普遍性的认知,以及随之而来的未能从道德层面看待与酒精相关的攻击行为,可能会使一些年轻人倾向于与酒精相关的攻击行为。干预措施可以针对:(1)认为男性与酒精相关的攻击行为普遍且无法控制的信念,以及(2)支撑这些信念的参与者对男子气概的功能失调的看法。