School of Education, Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan, Israel.
School of Education, Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan, Israel; Gonda Multidisciplinary Brain Research Center, Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan, Israel.
Res Dev Disabil. 2018 Mar;74:113-123. doi: 10.1016/j.ridd.2018.01.010. Epub 2018 Feb 3.
This study is the first to investigate the effectiveness of deep and shallow intervention programs in the acquisition of visual metaphor comprehension in individuals with non-specific intellectual disability (NSID; aged 15-59, N = 53) or Down syndrome (DS; aged 15-52, N = 50). The deep intervention program was based on dynamic assessment model for enhancing analogical thinking. The shallow intervention program involves memorizing a metaphorical relationship between pairs of pictures. Visual metaphor comprehension was measured by the construction of a metaphorical connection between pairs of pictures. The results indicated that both etiology groups exhibited poor understanding of visual metaphors before the intervention. A significant improvement was observed in both interventions and both etiology groups, with greater improvement among individuals who underwent the deep processing. Moreover, the latter procedure led to greater generalization ability. The results also indicated that vocabulary contributed significantly to understanding unstudied metaphors and that participants with poorer linguistic abilities exhibited greater improvement in their metaphorical thinking. Thus, individuals with ID with or without DS are able to recruit the higher-order cognitive abilities required for visual metaphor comprehension.
这项研究首次调查了深度和浅层干预方案在非特定智力障碍(NSID;年龄 15-59,N=53)或唐氏综合征(DS;年龄 15-52,N=50)个体中视觉隐喻理解能力习得方面的有效性。深度干预方案基于增强类比思维的动态评估模型。浅层干预方案涉及记忆图片对之间的隐喻关系。通过构建图片对之间的隐喻联系来测量视觉隐喻理解能力。结果表明,在干预之前,两个病因组的个体都表现出对视觉隐喻的理解较差。两种干预措施和两种病因组都观察到了显著的改善,深度处理组的改善更为明显。此外,后者程序导致了更大的泛化能力。结果还表明,词汇量对理解未研究过的隐喻有很大贡献,语言能力较差的参与者在隐喻思维方面的改善更为明显。因此,具有或不具有 DS 的 ID 个体能够招募到理解视觉隐喻所需的更高阶认知能力。