Abdelkarim Ahmad, Schween Dorothy, Ford Timothy
Dr. Abdelkarim is Associate Professor and Chair, Department of Orthodontics, University of Mississippi School of Dentistry; Dr. Schween is Professor and Associate Dean, College of Arts, Education, and Sciences, University of Louisiana at Monroe; and Dr. Ford is Assistant Professor and Research Scientist, Oklahoma Center for Education Policy, Department of Educational Leadership and Policy Studies, Jeannine Rainbolt College of Education, University of Oklahoma.
J Dent Educ. 2018 Feb;82(2):144-151. doi: 10.21815/JDE.018.019.
Problem-based learning (PBL) is a teaching method used in medical and dental education to promote students' problem-solving skills. It may also be a viable tool for interprofessional education in which medical and dental students learn together, collaborate, and learn about, from, and with each other. The aim of this study was to compare medical and dental faculty members' attitudes about and perceptions of PBL at 12 U.S. medical and dental schools known to use PBL. In 2015, 111 medical and 132 dental faculty members (combined n=243) from six medical and six dental schools completed a survey containing ten statements and an open comment section. The response rate was 42% of those who received the survey. In the results, the medical faculty participants showed significantly higher enthusiasm for and agreement with PBL benefits than did the dental faculty participants (p˂0.05). The two groups agreed that PBL should be used to supplement conventional teaching (p>0.05). There were no opposite attitudes or contrasts found between the two groups with regards to PBL. The strongest themes expressed by both groups were that PBL should not be used as the sole method of instruction and that students needed a solid foundation in the subject prior to engaging in PBL.
基于问题的学习(PBL)是医学和牙科教育中使用的一种教学方法,用于提高学生的问题解决能力。它也可能是跨专业教育的一种可行工具,在这种教育中,医学和牙科学生一起学习、协作,并相互学习、相互借鉴。本研究的目的是比较美国12所已知采用PBL的医学院和牙科学院的医学和牙科教员对PBL的态度和看法。2015年,来自六所医学院和六所牙科学院的111名医学教员和132名牙科教员(共计243人)完成了一项包含十条陈述和一个开放式评论部分的调查。回复率为收到调查问卷者的42%。结果显示,与牙科教员参与者相比,医学教员参与者对PBL的益处表现出明显更高的热情和认同度(p˂0.05)。两组都认为PBL应被用于补充传统教学(p>0.05)。在PBL方面,两组之间未发现相反的态度或差异。两组表达的最强烈主题是,PBL不应被用作唯一的教学方法,并且学生在参与PBL之前需要在该学科方面有坚实的基础。