Van Meel Chayenne, Op de Beeck Hans P
Laboratory of Biological Psychology, Brain and Cognition, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
Front Hum Neurosci. 2018 Jan 30;12:13. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2018.00013. eCollection 2018.
Humans can often recognize faces across viewpoints despite the large changes in low-level image properties a shift in viewpoint introduces. We present a behavioral and an fMRI adaptation experiment to investigate whether this viewpoint tolerance is reflected in the neural visual system and whether it can be manipulated through training. Participants saw training sequences of face images creating the appearance of a rotating head. Half of the sequences showed faces undergoing veridical changes in appearance across the rotation (non-morph condition). The other half were non-veridical: during rotation, the face simultaneously morphed into another face. This procedure should successfully associate frontal face views with side views of the same or a different identity, and, according to the temporal contiguity hypothesis, thus enhance viewpoint tolerance in the non-morph condition and/or break tolerance in the morph condition. Performance on the same/different task in the behavioral experiment ( = 20) was affected by training. There was a significant interaction between training (associated/not associated) and identity (same/different), mostly reflecting a higher confusion of different identities when they were associated during training. In the fMRI study ( = 20), fMRI adaptation effects were found for same-viewpoint images of untrained faces, but no adaptation for untrained faces was present across viewpoints. Only trained faces which were not morphed during training elicited a slight adaptation across viewpoints in face-selective regions. However, both in the behavioral and in the neural data the effects were small and weak from a statistical point of view. Overall, we conclude that the findings are not inconsistent with the proposal that temporal contiguity can influence viewpoint tolerance, with more evidence for tolerance when faces are not morphed during training.
尽管视角的转变会导致低层次图像属性发生巨大变化,但人类通常仍能从不同视角识别面孔。我们进行了一项行为实验和一项功能磁共振成像适应实验,以研究这种视角耐受性是否在神经视觉系统中有所体现,以及它是否可以通过训练来操控。参与者观看了一系列人脸图像的训练序列,这些序列营造出头部旋转的效果。其中一半序列展示的是人脸在旋转过程中外观发生真实变化(非变形条件)。另一半则不真实:在旋转过程中,人脸同时变形为另一张脸。这个过程应该能成功地将正面人脸视图与相同或不同身份的侧面视图联系起来,并且根据时间连续性假设,从而增强非变形条件下的视角耐受性和/或打破变形条件下的耐受性。行为实验(n = 20)中在相同/不同任务上的表现受到了训练的影响。训练(关联/未关联)和身份(相同/不同)之间存在显著交互作用,主要表现为当不同身份在训练中被关联时,对它们的混淆程度更高。在功能磁共振成像研究(n = 20)中,发现未训练人脸的同视角图像存在功能磁共振成像适应效应,但未训练人脸在不同视角之间不存在适应效应。只有在训练期间未变形的训练人脸在人脸选择区域中引发了轻微的跨视角适应效应。然而,从统计学角度来看,无论是行为数据还是神经数据,这些效应都很小且不明显。总体而言,我们得出结论,这些发现与时间连续性可以影响视角耐受性的观点并不矛盾,当人脸在训练期间未变形时,有更多证据支持耐受性。