Chaidir Lidya, Annisa Jessi, Dian Sofiati, Parwati Ida, Alisjahbana Arlisa, Purnama Feby, van der Zanden Adri, Ganiem Ahmad Rizal, van Crevel Reinout
TB-HIV Research Center, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Padjadjaran/Hasan Sadikin Hospital, Eijkman 38, Bandung, Indonesia, 40161.
TB-HIV Research Center, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Padjadjaran/Hasan Sadikin Hospital, Eijkman 38, Bandung, Indonesia, 40161.
Diagn Microbiol Infect Dis. 2018 May;91(1):42-46. doi: 10.1016/j.diagmicrobio.2018.01.004. Epub 2018 Jan 9.
We evaluated microbiological diagnosis of tuberculous (TB) meningitis in a referral hospital in Indonesia. Over a ten-year period, we examined cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) samples of 1180 adult meningitis suspects. Sensitivity of different methods was compared, and results were stratified for HIV status, disease severity, and CSF volume. TB meningitis was bacteriologically confirmed in 501 patients. Using clinical diagnosis as reference standard (n = 713), sensitivity of different methods was 12.2% (86/703) for microscopy, 42% (73/174) for Xpert MTB/RIF, 46.0% (163/354) for solid culture, 48.8% (332/680) for liquid culture, and 64.0% (212/331) for in-house PCR. Head to head comparisons in 654 patients showed a higher yield of in-house PCR (32.3%) compared to culture (15.6%, P < 0.01). Microscopic observation of drug susceptibility (MODS) culture more rapidly became positive compared to other culture methods. Yield of culture was lower in HIV-infected (39/105) than in HIV-negative patients (N = 316/585; P < 0.01). Molecular and culture methods gave higher yields in patients with more severe disease (P < 0.01). CSF volume of ≥6 ml increased the yield of culture (42.8% versus 12.1% for CSF <6 ml, P < 0.01) and ZN-microscopy (18.3% versus 1.9% for CSF <6 ml, P < 0.01). CSF centrifugation had no clear effect on sensitivity of Xpert MTB/RIF. ZN-microscopy lacks sensitivity for diagnosis of TB meningitis. For molecular assays, in-house IS6110-PCR is more sensitive than Xpert MTB/RIF. MODS culture has a clear advantage in terms of speed. Large CSF volumes are necessary for all tests. The effect of CSF processing for Xpert MTB/RIF needs further study.
我们在印度尼西亚的一家转诊医院对结核性脑膜炎的微生物学诊断进行了评估。在十年期间,我们检查了1180例成年脑膜炎疑似患者的脑脊液(CSF)样本。比较了不同方法的敏感性,并根据HIV状态、疾病严重程度和脑脊液量对结果进行了分层。501例患者的结核性脑膜炎得到细菌学确诊。以临床诊断作为参考标准(n = 713),显微镜检查的敏感性为12.2%(86/703),Xpert MTB/RIF为42%(73/174),固体培养为46.0%(163/354),液体培养为48.8%(332/680),内部PCR为64.0%(212/331)。在654例患者中进行的直接比较显示,与培养(15.6%,P < 0.01)相比,内部PCR的阳性率更高(32.3%)。与其他培养方法相比,药物敏感性显微镜观察(MODS)培养更快呈阳性。HIV感染患者(39/105)的培养阳性率低于HIV阴性患者(N = 316/585;P < 0.01)。分子和培养方法在病情更严重的患者中阳性率更高(P < 0.01)。脑脊液量≥6 ml可提高培养阳性率(脑脊液<6 ml时为42.8%,而脑脊液<6 ml时为12.1%,P < 0.01)和齐-尼氏显微镜检查阳性率(脑脊液<6 ml时为18.3%,而脑脊液<6 ml时为1.9%,P < 0.01)。脑脊液离心对Xpert MTB/RIF的敏感性没有明显影响。齐-尼氏显微镜检查对结核性脑膜炎的诊断缺乏敏感性。对于分子检测,内部IS6110-PCR比Xpert MTB/RIF更敏感。MODS培养在速度方面具有明显优势。所有检测都需要大量脑脊液。脑脊液处理对Xpert MTB/RIF的影响需要进一步研究。