Paterson-Brown S, Eckersley J R, Sim A J, Dudley H A
Br J Surg. 1986 Dec;73(12):1022-4. doi: 10.1002/bjs.1800731230.
When patients are admitted to hospital with acute abdominal pain, clinicians, irrespective of a specific diagnosis, intuitively select three diagnostic classes: operation definitely required (Group A); operation definitely not required (Group B); need for operation uncertain (Group C). The last is followed either by a precautionary laparotomy or a variable period of observation/investigation. We have studied prospectively the influence of laparoscopy on the distribution between these classes and particularly on outcome in group C. One hundred and twenty-five consecutive patients with abdominal pain severe enough for emergency admission have been classified by one of two admitting surgeons (SHO/registrar), who also expressed in group C a view on how they would proceed--operation or observation. Group C were then laparoscoped. The procedure confirmed a provisional view that laparotomy was needed in 11 of 15 patients. In the 'observation' sub-group the provisional decision was confirmed in 14 of 16 and early discharge followed in most. Six inappropriate decisions were thus avoided. Seven management decisions in group A and 4 in group B proved incorrect (11/94: 12 per cent). The majority were potentially recognizable by laparoscopy. Though relatively high rates of successful decision making are achieved with conventional clinical techniques, they can be further improved by laparoscopy. This procedure is particularly applicable in the management of patients with acute abdominal pain without a definite diagnosis, or when appendicitis is regarded as an established diagnosis.
当患者因急性腹痛入院时,临床医生无论具体诊断如何,都会直观地将其分为三类:肯定需要手术(A组);肯定不需要手术(B组);手术必要性不确定(C组)。对于C组患者,要么进行预防性剖腹手术,要么进行一段可变时长的观察/检查。我们前瞻性地研究了腹腔镜检查对这些分类之间分布的影响,特别是对C组患者结局的影响。125例因腹痛严重而急诊入院的连续患者由两名住院外科医生(住院医师/注册医师)之一进行分类,这两名医生还对C组患者的处理方式(手术或观察)表达了自己的看法。然后对C组患者进行腹腔镜检查。该操作证实了初步观点,即15例患者中有11例需要剖腹手术。在“观察”亚组中,16例中有14例的初步决定得到证实,大多数患者随后提前出院。因此避免了6个不恰当的决定。A组有7个处理决定和B组有4个处理决定被证明是错误的(11/94:12%)。大多数错误决定通过腹腔镜检查可能是可以识别的。虽然采用传统临床技术能实现相对较高的正确决策率,但通过腹腔镜检查可以进一步提高。该操作特别适用于处理未明确诊断的急性腹痛患者,或者当阑尾炎被视为确诊时的患者。