Berenbaum M C, Akande S L, Bonnett R, Kaur H, Ioannou S, White R D, Winfield U J
Br J Cancer. 1986 Nov;54(5):717-25. doi: 10.1038/bjc.1986.232.
We compared para-, meta- and ortho-isomers of meso-tetra(hydroxyphenyl)porphyrin (p-, m- and o-THPP) and the potassium salt of the para compound (K-p-THPP) with haematoporphyrin derivative (HpD) and Photofrin II in their ability to sensitise tumours, skin and brain to light. HpD and Photofrin II induced modest tumour photosensitisation at the cost of substantial skin and brain sensitisation. At doses low enough to keep sensitisation of these normal tissues within acceptable limits, tumour sensitisation was sufficient to give necrosis only approximately 2 mm deep after exposure to 10 J cm-2 light. In contrast, doses of p-THPP, K-p-THPP and m-THPP that produced skin and brain sensitivity within acceptable limits sensitised tumours enough to give 4-9 mm necrosis after 10 J cm-2 light. m-THPP was, on a molar basis, about 25-30 times as potent as HpD and Photofrin II in sensitising tumours. o-THPP was also a potent tumour photosensitiser, but induced a prohibitive degree of skin photosensitivity even at low doses. It is unlikely that these differences in relative selectivity are due to differences in such photophysical parameters as optimum activating wavelength (which would affect tissue penetration by light), or light absorption, and physicochemical factors that determine tissue localisation may be involved. The high tumour sensitising potency and favourable tissue selectivity of m-THPP, p-THPP and K-p-THPP make them promising candidates for clinical tumour phototherapy.
我们比较了中位四(羟苯基)卟啉的对位、间位和邻位异构体(p-、m-和o-THPP)以及对位化合物的钾盐(K-p-THPP)与血卟啉衍生物(HpD)和光卟啉II在使肿瘤、皮肤和脑对光敏感方面的能力。HpD和光卟啉II诱导适度的肿瘤光敏感,但以显著的皮肤和脑敏感为代价。在剂量低到足以将这些正常组织的敏感程度控制在可接受范围内时,肿瘤敏感程度仅在暴露于10 J/cm²光照后足以产生约2毫米深的坏死。相比之下,在可接受范围内产生皮肤和脑敏感的p-THPP、K-p-THPP和m-THPP剂量,使肿瘤敏感程度足以在10 J/cm²光照后产生4 - 9毫米的坏死。以摩尔为基础,m-THPP在使肿瘤敏感方面的效力约为HpD和光卟啉II的25 - 30倍。o-THPP也是一种有效的肿瘤光致敏剂,但即使在低剂量下也会引起过高程度的皮肤光敏感。这些相对选择性的差异不太可能是由于诸如最佳激活波长(这会影响光在组织中的穿透)或光吸收等光物理参数的差异,可能涉及决定组织定位的物理化学因素。m-THPP、p-THPP和K-p-THPP的高肿瘤致敏效力和良好的组织选择性使它们成为临床肿瘤光疗的有前景的候选物。