Nikitina Svetlana, Didino Daniele, Baez Marcos, Casati Fabio
Tomsk Polytechnic University, Tomsk, Russian Federation.
Department of Information Engineering and Computer Science, University of Trento, Trento, Italy.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2018 Feb 27;6(2):e40. doi: 10.2196/mhealth.7531.
Regular physical activity has a positive effect on physical health, well-being, and life satisfaction of older adults. However, engaging in regular physical activity can be challenging for the elderly population because of reduced mobility, low motivation, or lack of the proper infrastructures in their communities.
The objective of this paper was to study the feasibility of home-based online group training-under different group cohesion settings-and its effects on adherence and well-being among Russian older adults. We focused particularly on the technology usability and usage and on the adherence to the training (in light of premeasures of social support, enjoyment of physical activity, and leg muscle strength). As a secondary objective, we also explored the effects of the technology-supported intervention on subjective well-being and loneliness.
Two pilot trials were carried out exploring two different group cohesion settings (weak cohesion and strong cohesion) in the period from 2015 to 2016 in Tomsk, Russian Federation. A total of 44 older adults (59-83 years) participated in the two pilots and followed a strength and balance training program (Otago) for 8 weeks with the help of a tablet-based virtual gym app. Participants in each pilot were assigned to an interaction condition, representing the online group exercising, and an individual condition, representing a home-based individual training. Both conditions featured persuasion strategies but differed in the ability to socialize and train together.
Both interaction and individual groups reported a high usability of the technology. Trainees showed a high level of technology acceptance and, particularly, a high score in intention to future use (4.2-5.0 on a 5-point Likert scale). Private texting (short service message [SMS]) was used more than public texting, and the strong cohesion condition resulted in more messages per user. Joint participations to training sessions (copresence) were higher for the social group with higher cohesion. The overall adherence to the training was 74% (SD 27%). Higher levels of social support at baseline were associated with higher adherence in the low cohesion condition (F1,18=5.23, P=.03), whereas in the high cohesion, such association was not found. Overall improvement in the satisfaction with life score was observed between pre and post measures (F1,31=5.85, P=.02), but no decrease in loneliness.
Online group exercising was proven feasible among healthy independently living older adults in Russia. The pilots suggest that a physical training performed in a virtual environment positively affect the life satisfaction of the trainees, but it does not provide support for a decrease in loneliness. High cohesion groups are preferable for group exercising, especially to mitigate effects of low social support on adherence. Further research in motivating group interactions in training settings is needed.
定期进行体育活动对老年人的身体健康、幸福感和生活满意度有积极影响。然而,由于行动不便、动力不足或社区缺乏适当的基础设施,老年人进行定期体育活动可能具有挑战性。
本文旨在研究在不同群体凝聚力环境下基于家庭的在线团体训练的可行性及其对俄罗斯老年人坚持训练情况和幸福感的影响。我们特别关注技术的可用性和使用情况以及对训练的坚持程度(鉴于社会支持、体育活动乐趣和腿部肌肉力量的预先测量)。作为次要目标,我们还探讨了技术支持干预对主观幸福感和孤独感的影响。
2015年至2016年期间,在俄罗斯联邦托木斯克进行了两项试点试验,探索两种不同的群体凝聚力环境(弱凝聚力和强凝聚力)。共有44名老年人(59 - 83岁)参与了这两项试点试验,并借助基于平板电脑的虚拟健身房应用程序,进行了为期8周的力量和平衡训练计划(奥塔哥训练计划)。每个试点试验的参与者被分配到一个代表在线团体锻炼的互动组和一个代表家庭个人训练的个体组。两种情况都采用了说服策略,但在社交和一起训练的能力方面有所不同。
互动组和个体组都报告了该技术的高可用性。受训者对技术的接受程度很高,特别是在未来使用意愿方面得分很高(在5分制李克特量表上为4.2 - 5.0)。私人短信(短消息服务[SMS])的使用比公共短信更多,并且强凝聚力环境下每个用户发送的消息更多。凝聚力较高的社会群体参加训练课程(共同在场)的情况更多。训练的总体坚持率为74%(标准差27%)。基线时较高水平的社会支持与低凝聚力环境下较高的坚持率相关(F1,18 = 5.23,P = 0.03),而在高凝聚力环境下未发现这种关联。在测量前和测量后观察到生活满意度得分总体有所改善(F,31 = 5.85,P = 0.02),但孤独感没有降低。
在俄罗斯健康独立生活的老年人中,在线团体锻炼被证明是可行的。试点试验表明,在虚拟环境中进行的体育训练对受训者的生活满意度有积极影响,但对降低孤独感没有帮助。高凝聚力群体更适合团体锻炼,特别是为了减轻低社会支持对坚持训练的影响。需要进一步研究如何在训练环境中激发团体互动。