Marked asymmetry in vertical force (but not contact times) during running in ACL reconstructed athletes <9 months post-surgery despite meeting functional criteria for return to sport.

OBJECTIVES

Compare maximum plantar force (Fmax) during running in soccer players following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) as they pass return to sport (RTS) criteria.

DESIGN

Case control study.

METHODS

Soccer players after ACLR (n=16) and matched healthy controls (n=16) ran on a treadmill at 12, 14 and 16km/h while plantar loading data was measured using an in-shoe pressure system (Pedar-X, Novel). Fmax and contact time of the injured and uninjured limbs in athletes <9months post-ACLR and those ≥9months ACLR were compared to healthy players (no ACLR).

RESULTS

Significant differences with large effect sizes in Fmax asymmetry were seen at all running speeds for the athletes <9months ACLR compared to those ≥9months, and the healthy subjects. Fmax difference peaked at 16km/h; 32±11%BW in <9months ACLR group compared to 6±5%BW in ≥9months group; ES=1.67, p<0.01. There was a non-significant trend for increasing asymmetry with increasing speed for subjects who were <9months after ACLR while the reverse was true for those ≥9 months and the healthy subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

Relatively large unloading of the ACLR limb (but not differences in contact times) are seen during running for athletes <9months post-ACLR despite having completed functional criteria required to permit RTS training. These asymmetries appear to slightly increase with increasing speed, and the reverse is true for healthy controls and those ≥9months after ACLR surgery.