Division of Clinical Epidemiology and Aging Research, German Cancer Research Center (DKFZ), Im Neuenheimer Feld 581, 69120, Heidelberg, Germany. Heidelberg Medical Faculty, University of Heidelberg, Im Neuenheimer Feld 672, 69120, Heidelberg, Germany.
J Breath Res. 2018 Apr 4;12(3):036009. doi: 10.1088/1752-7163/aab5be.
Regular screening for gastric cancer (GC) is based on invasive upper gastrointestinal endoscopy and is limited to few high-incidence countries. As GC is a major cause of cancer death worldwide, a non-invasive, simple screening test is of value. We assessed the prevalence of preclinical GC and the corresponding numbers needed to screen (NNS) to detect GC cases both without and with preselection using breath tests from the literature in various populations.
Using age- and sex-specific GC incidence data and rates of transition from preclinical to clinical GC, we estimated the prevalences of preclinical GC worldwide in populations aged 50-74 years, and we evaluated the accuracy of breath testing for GC detection based on published studies. We then derived the expected positive predictive values for breath testing in populations with different preclinical GC prevalences.
Four studies reporting the sensitivity and specificity of breath tests were identified, and summary estimates of 83% sensitivity and 91% specificity were derived by meta-analysis. The estimates of the overall prevalence of preclinical GC were <0.5% in men and <0.2% in women aged 50-74 years across different regions of the world. The positive predictive values, the prevalence among breath test positive people, were approximately nine-fold higher in all populations, resulting in an approximately nine-fold lower NNS to detect one GC case when breath tests were used for preselection for screening.
Given the low prevalence of preclinical GC, non-invasive breath tests show promise for making screening more efficient. Further validation of breath tests and evidence on the rates of transition from preclinical to clinical GC are needed to validate the breath test approach.
常规胃癌(GC)筛查基于有创性上消化道内镜检查,且仅限于少数高发国家。由于 GC 是全球癌症死亡的主要原因,因此一种非侵入性、简单的筛查检测方法具有重要价值。我们评估了文献中来自不同人群的呼吸试验在无和有预选情况下检测 GC 病例的临床前 GC 的患病率以及相应的筛查人数(NNS)。
使用年龄和性别特异性 GC 发病率数据以及从临床前到临床 GC 的转化率,我们估计了全球 50-74 岁人群中临床前 GC 的流行率,并根据已发表的研究评估了呼吸试验检测 GC 的准确性。然后,我们从不同临床前 GC 流行率的人群中得出了呼吸试验的预期阳性预测值。
确定了四项报告呼吸试验敏感性和特异性的研究,荟萃分析得出的综合估计值为 83%的敏感性和 91%的特异性。全球不同地区 50-74 岁人群中临床前 GC 的总体患病率估计值男性<0.5%,女性<0.2%。阳性预测值,即呼吸试验阳性人群中的患病率,在所有人群中均高出约九倍,因此,当使用呼吸试验进行预选进行筛查时,检测一个 GC 病例的 NNS 约降低九倍。
鉴于临床前 GC 的低患病率,非侵入性呼吸试验显示出提高筛查效率的潜力。需要进一步验证呼吸试验和从临床前到临床 GC 的转化率的证据,以验证呼吸试验方法。