A systematic and quantitative evaluation of plantar stimulation: The effect of type, pattern, force of stimulation in eliciting an accurate plantar response.

OBJECTIVES

Systematic and quantitative evaluation of the plantar reflex has been infrequently studied in the past and can help assess the vexing variables encountered in its elicitation. The objective of this study was to determine the effect of type, pattern and force of stimulation in eliciting an accurate plantar response in patients with pyramidal dysfunction and healthy individuals.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A special instrument was designed to give a predesigned force of stimulus. The plantar surface of foot was divided into nine parts and point and stroke stimulations were studied systematically in pyramidal weakness feet (cases) and healthy control feet (controls) with predefined forces. Results were tabulated and statistically analysed.

RESULTS

Stroke stimulation was superior to point stimulation in eliciting plantar response. There was no significant difference in the responses to the three predefined forces used for stroke stimulations. Sensitivity of Babinski sign was 72.9% and specificity was 100%. In pyramidal weakness feet, extensor responses were significantly elicited from lateral starting stroke patterns (67%) and on moving medially they were replaced by flexor responses (44%). Withdrawal responses increased with the stimulations reaching the distal foot and with the curvilinear component of stimulations. Sensitivity responses (related to the sensitivity of an individual) contaminate the plantar response and occasionally make its interpretation difficult. In subjects with bilateral sensitivity with unilateral disease, knowing the sensitivity pattern on the normal side improved the interpretation of plantar response on the abnormal side.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on this study, the optimal method for eliciting Babinski sign accurately is to stroke the lateral aspect of the sole of the foot in a straight line up to mid foot. This should be performed in both feet three times, and if the weakness is unilateral, it should be performed in the normal leg first to aid interpretation of the affected leg.