Joshi Urvish, Vyas Sheetal
Department of Community Medicine, AMC MET Medical College, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India.
Indian J Community Med. 2018 Jan-Mar;43(1):37-39. doi: 10.4103/ijcm.IJCM_375_16.
Current programs in medical education technology concentrate mainly upon "how-to-teach." The focus is needed on learner's memory retention too. An innovative strategy like concept mapping might be a way forward. The study was carried out to assess its effectiveness and to know students' perceptions.
During community medicine classes, a student-group was sensitized on how to make and use concept maps out of taught contents. At the end of epidemiology exercises sessions, this group was given additional minutes to prepare concept maps, interact, and brainstorm followed by quick QA session. Others were taught same contents in conventional way. Performances of both groups were assessed in one immediate (term-ending) and one distant (preliminary) exam. Feedback was also taken from study group.
Study group consistently scored higher in both exams. Difference in scored mean marks was highly significant in term-ending-examination ( < 0.0001, = 5.754, df = 121.9). Largely positive feedback was received on utility of concept maps in memorizing, confidence-boosting, and understanding subject. Felt need for innovations in conventional teaching-learning (T-L) was palpable.
Time has come to start focusing on enhancing students' learning. Performance-enhancing utility of concept maps is proven and should be integrated in regular T-L.
当前医学教育技术课程主要集中在“如何教学”上。也需要关注学习者的记忆保持情况。像概念图这样的创新策略可能是一条前进的道路。开展这项研究以评估其有效性并了解学生的看法。
在社区医学课程中,一个学生小组就如何根据所学内容制作和使用概念图进行了培训。在流行病学练习课程结束时,给这个小组额外的时间来准备概念图、进行互动和头脑风暴,随后进行快速问答环节。其他学生则以传统方式学习相同的内容。在一次即时(学期末)考试和一次远程(预科)考试中评估了两组的表现。还从研究小组收集了反馈意见。
研究小组在两次考试中得分一直较高。在学期末考试中,得分平均分的差异非常显著(<0.0001,F = 5.754,自由度 = 121.9)。关于概念图在记忆、增强信心和理解学科方面的实用性,收到了大量积极反馈。人们明显感到需要对传统教学学习(T-L)进行创新。
现在是时候开始关注提高学生的学习了。概念图提高成绩的实用性已得到证明,应将其纳入常规的教学学习中。