Folayan Morenike Oluwatoyin, Haire Bridget Gabriella, Adeniyi Abiola A, Adeyemo Wasiu Lanre
a College of Health Sciences, Faculty of Dentistry , Obafemi Awolowo University , Ile-Ife , Osun , Nigeria.
b Kirby Institute for Infection and Immunity in Society , Sydney , NSW , Australia.
New Bioeth. 2018 Jul;24(2):135-149. doi: 10.1080/20502877.2018.1448251. Epub 2018 Mar 13.
Dental caries is the main oral health challenge for children in Nigeria. Concern about its negative impact makes screening for caries in children an attractive public health strategy. The ability to detect the preclinical phase of caries, the availability of screening tools with high accuracy, and the possibility of treatment before onset of clinical symptoms with significant cost and health benefits, makes it appropriate for screening. However in Nigeria, the poor availability of highly specific and sensitive screening tools, poor access to oral health care and concerns with pre-screening consent, raise the question of the appropriateness of conducting screening programmes for children. We argue that a number of structural challenges associated with poor uptake of oral health care services need to be addressed before screening for caries can be considered ethically appropriate. These include facilitating access of children to quality oral health care and a systematic national approach to oral health implementation. Failure to address challenges associated with dental service utilization by children in Nigeria increases the risk of screening programmes promoting inequitable access to oral health care services.
龋齿是尼日利亚儿童面临的主要口腔健康挑战。对其负面影响的担忧使得儿童龋齿筛查成为一项有吸引力的公共卫生策略。能够检测龋齿的临床前期阶段、具备高精度筛查工具以及在临床症状出现之前进行治疗的可能性,且具有显著的成本效益和健康效益,这些因素使得筛查变得适宜。然而在尼日利亚,高度特异性和敏感性筛查工具的匮乏、获得口腔保健服务的机会有限以及对筛查前同意的担忧,引发了对儿童开展筛查项目是否合适的质疑。我们认为,在龋齿筛查被视为符合伦理道德之前,需要解决一些与口腔保健服务利用率低相关的结构性挑战。这些挑战包括促使儿童能够获得优质的口腔保健服务以及采用系统的国家口腔健康实施方法。如果不解决尼日利亚儿童在牙科服务利用方面的相关挑战,筛查项目就会增加促进口腔保健服务不公平获取的风险。