Pain Center, Nemours Hospital, Nemours Cedex.
Faculty of Medicine, Henri Mondor Hospital.
Clin J Pain. 2018 Sep;34(9):831-837. doi: 10.1097/AJP.0000000000000607.
The efficacy of ketamine in relieving complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) lacks predictive factors. The value of three-phase bone scintigraphy (TPBS) was assessed for this purpose.
TPBS was performed in 105 patients with unilateral, focal CRPS of type 1 before 5 days of ketamine infusions. Tracer uptake was measured in the region of interest concerned by CRPS and the contralateral homologous region. For the 3 scintigraphic phases (vascular, tissular, and bone phases), an asymmetry ratio of fixation was calculated between the affected and the unaffected sides (vascular phase [VPr], tissular phase [TPr], and bone phase [BPr]). Ketamine efficacy was assessed on pain intensity scores.
Ketamine-induced pain relief did not correlate with VPr, TPr, and BPr, but with the ratios of these ratios: BPr/TPr (r=0.32, P=0.009), BPr/VPr (r=0.34, P=0.005), and TPr/VPr (r=0.23, P=0.02). The optimum cut-off value for predicting the response to ketamine therapy was >1.125 for BPr/TPr, >1.075 for BPr/VPr, and >0.935 for TPr/VPr. The combination of increased values of BPr/TPr, BPr/VPr, and TPr/VPr was highly significantly associated with ketamine therapy outcome.
The relative hyperfixation of the radioactive tracer in the limb region concerned by CRPS in phases 2 and 3 versus phase 1 of TPBS correlated positively to the analgesic efficacy of ketamine. This study shows for the first time the potential predictive value of TPBS regarding ketamine therapy outcome. In addition, these results suggest that the analgesic action of ketamine is not restricted to "central" mechanisms, but may also involve "peripheral" mechanisms related to tissue inflammation and bone remodeling.
氯胺酮缓解复杂性区域疼痛综合征(CRPS)的疗效缺乏预测因素。为此,评估了三相骨闪烁扫描(TPBS)的价值。
在接受氯胺酮输注前 5 天,对 105 例单侧、局灶性 1 型 CRPS 患者进行了 TPBS。在受 CRPS 影响的区域和对侧同源区域测量示踪剂摄取。对于 3 个闪烁扫描相(血管相、组织相和骨相),计算受影响侧和未受影响侧之间的固定不对称比(血管相[VPr]、组织相[TPr]和骨相[BPr])。根据疼痛强度评分评估氯胺酮的疗效。
氯胺酮引起的疼痛缓解与 VPr、TPr 和 BPr 无关,但与这些比值的比值有关:BPr/TPr(r=0.32,P=0.009)、BPr/VPr(r=0.34,P=0.005)和 TPr/VPr(r=0.23,P=0.02)。预测氯胺酮治疗反应的最佳截断值为 BPr/TPr>1.125、BPr/VPr>1.075 和 TPr/VPr>0.935。BPr/TPr、BPr/VPr 和 TPr/VPr 值升高的组合与氯胺酮治疗结果高度相关。
在 TPBS 的 2 相和 3 相中,放射性示踪剂在受 CRPS 影响的肢体区域的相对固定与氯胺酮的镇痛疗效呈正相关。这项研究首次表明,TPBS 对氯胺酮治疗结果具有潜在的预测价值。此外,这些结果表明,氯胺酮的镇痛作用不仅限于“中枢”机制,还可能涉及与组织炎症和骨重塑有关的“外周”机制。