Mavromatis Marina V, Solano Mauricio, Thelen Michael Y
Department Clinical Sciences, Tufts University Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine, North Grafton, MA, 01536.
SAS Institute Inc, Cary, NC.
Vet Radiol Ultrasound. 2018 Jul;59(4):381-386. doi: 10.1111/vru.12611. Epub 2018 Mar 15.
There are clear differences in the normal radiographic appearance of the abdominal organs between a left lateral vs. a right lateral view. While a few veterinary academic institutions have transitioned to a three-view abdominal radiographic study protocol, obtaining only two views of the canine abdomen remains the current standard in veterinary medicine. In this combined retrospective and prospective, case-controlled study, 48 canine patients presenting with signs of acute abdomen were recruited. Four board-certified veterinary radiologists and four general practice veterinarians with greater than 3 years of experience in small animal practice were asked to determine if 10 predetermined findings were present within the set of images and if surgery was recommended based on those findings. Image readers were unaware of the clinical history. Three-view studies did not yield statistically significantly greater accuracy than two-view studies when evaluating all readers together. No statistically significant associations between the availability of the third view and increased accuracy or confidence were found in evaluations of general practitioners specifically. Evaluation of three-view radiographic examination, as compared to two-view examination, did not have perceived or statistically significantly increased diagnostic utility. Based on our findings, there is no statistically increased utility to justify a standard three-view abdominal radiographic examination over a two-view study for canines presenting with signs of acute abdomen.
左侧卧位与右侧卧位时腹部器官的正常放射影像存在明显差异。虽然一些兽医学术机构已过渡到采用腹部放射影像的三视角研究方案,但目前兽医学中犬腹部仅采用两个视角的放射影像检查仍是标准做法。在这项回顾性与前瞻性相结合的病例对照研究中,招募了48例出现急腹症症状的犬类患者。邀请了四位具有执业资格认证的兽医放射科医生和四位在小动物临床实践中拥有超过3年经验的全科兽医,让他们判断在一组影像中是否存在10项预先确定的病症表现,以及是否根据这些表现建议进行手术。影像阅片者对临床病史并不知情。当综合评估所有阅片者时,三视角检查在准确性方面相比双视角检查并无统计学上的显著提高。在专门针对全科兽医的评估中,未发现第三视角的可用性与准确性或信心增强之间存在统计学上的显著关联。与双视角检查相比,三视角放射影像检查在诊断效用方面并未在认知上或统计学上有显著提高。基于我们的研究结果,对于出现急腹症症状的犬类,与双视角检查相比,采用标准的三视角腹部放射影像检查在统计学上并没有更高的效用。