Slack Daniel R, Grisby Shaunda, Dike Uzoamaka Kimberly, Kohli Harjeet
Surgery Department, Waterbury Hospital, Waterbury, Connecticut.
Surgery Department, Easton Hospital, Easton, Pennsylvania.
JSLS. 2018 Jan-Mar;22(1). doi: 10.4293/JSLS.2017.00087.
Many risk factors have been identified in minimally invasive cholecystectomies that lead to higher complications and conversion rates. No study that we encountered looked at nonvisualization of the gallbladder (GB) during surgery as a risk factor. We hypothesized that nonvisualization was associated with an increased risk of complications and could be an early intraoperative identifier of a higher risk procedure. Recognizing this could allow surgeons to be aware of potential risks and to be more likely to convert to open for the safety of the patient.
We looked at minimally invasive cholecystectomies performed at our institution from January 2015 through April 2016 and had the performing resident fill out a survey after the surgery. Outcomes were conversion rates, intraoperative complications, and blood loss and were analyzed via Pearson χ test or Mann-Whitney U test.
The primary outcome showed a conversion rate of 37% in nonvisualized GBs versus 0% in visualized ( = .001). Secondary outcomes showed significant differences in GB perforations (74% vs 13%, = .001), omental vessel bleeding (16% vs. 0%, = .005), and EBL (46 mL vs 29 mL, = .001).
Intraoperative nonvisualization of the GB after adequate positioning caused significantly increased risk of intraoperative complications and conversion. This knowledge could be useful during intraoperative assessment, to decide whether a case should be continued as a minimally invasive procedure or converted early to help reduce risk to the patient. Further randomized controlled studies should be performed to further demonstrate the value of this assessment.
在微创胆囊切除术中已确定了许多导致更高并发症和中转开腹率的危险因素。我们未发现有研究将手术期间胆囊未显影视为危险因素。我们假设胆囊未显影与并发症风险增加相关,并且可能是高风险手术的早期术中标识。认识到这一点可以让外科医生意识到潜在风险,并更有可能为了患者安全中转开腹。
我们研究了2015年1月至2016年4月在我们机构进行的微创胆囊切除术,并让主刀住院医师在术后填写一份调查问卷。观察指标为中转开腹率、术中并发症、失血量,并通过Pearson卡方检验或Mann-Whitney U检验进行分析。
主要观察指标显示,胆囊未显影组的中转开腹率为37%,而胆囊显影组为0%(P = 0.001)。次要观察指标显示胆囊穿孔(74%对13%,P = 0.001)、网膜血管出血(16%对0%,P = 0.005)和失血量(46 mL对29 mL,P = 0.001)存在显著差异。
在适当体位后术中胆囊未显影会显著增加术中并发症和中转开腹的风险。这一认识在术中评估期间可能有用,以决定一个病例是否应继续作为微创手术进行或尽早中转,以帮助降低患者风险。应进行进一步的随机对照研究以进一步证明这种评估的价值。