Granfeldt H, Nylander E
Clin Physiol. 1987 Jun;7(3):209-16. doi: 10.1111/j.1475-097x.1987.tb00162.x.
Many studies have investigated different ECG and vectorcardiographic (VCG): criteria for diagnosis of left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH). In some investigations VCG was more sensitive than ECG in this respect. This study was performed to elucidate whether it is possible also to determine the degree of LVH using VCG. Eighty cardiovascularly healthy subjects aged 15-39 were investigated with ECG, VCG (Frank system) and echocardiography. The echocardiographic left ventricular (LV) mass has been shown by others to correlate closely to the anatomical and the angiographically determined LV mass and was used as reference standard. Thirty-eight of the subjects were endurance sportsmen and had a LV mass above standard reference limits. The measured ECG variables were R-amplitude in a VL, I, V5, V6, S-amplitude in V1 and SV1 + RV5/V6 and the VCG variables were QRS spatial area and circumference and left maximal spatial vector. The sensitivity and specificity of single criteria tested were similar for ECG and VCG in the quantitative determination of LVH. The correlations between ECG-amplitudes and the magnitude of the LV mass were weak. The correlations were higher with the VCG-variables, QRS spatial circumference being superior to the others, but not good enough to permit an estimation of the LV mass in individual subjects. In conclusion, normal VCG variables were highly specific for a normal LV mass but in individuals with LVH, VCG was not useful for the estimation of the LV mass.
许多研究调查了不同的心电图(ECG)和向量心电图(VCG)诊断左心室肥厚(LVH)的标准。在一些研究中,在这方面VCG比ECG更敏感。本研究旨在阐明是否也可以使用VCG来确定LVH的程度。对80名年龄在15 - 39岁的心血管健康受试者进行了ECG、VCG(Frank系统)和超声心动图检查。其他人已表明超声心动图测得的左心室(LV)质量与解剖学和血管造影确定的LV质量密切相关,并将其用作参考标准。其中38名受试者是耐力运动员,其LV质量高于标准参考限值。测量的ECG变量为VL、I、V5、V6导联的R波振幅,V1导联的S波振幅以及SV1 + RV5/V6,VCG变量为QRS空间面积、周长和左最大空间向量。在LVH的定量测定中,ECG和VCG单一标准测试的敏感性和特异性相似。ECG振幅与LV质量大小之间的相关性较弱。与VCG变量的相关性更高,QRS空间周长优于其他变量,但仍不足以用于估计个体受试者的LV质量。总之,正常的VCG变量对正常LV质量具有高度特异性,但在LVH个体中,VCG对LV质量的估计无用。