Louik C, Mitchell A A, Werler M M, Hanson J W, Shapiro S
N Engl J Med. 1987 Aug 20;317(8):474-8. doi: 10.1056/NEJM198708203170803.
Several studies have found no increase in the overall frequency of birth defects in association with the use of spermicides, but the possibility of an increase in specific defects remains. We evaluated this possibility in a large case-control study. Infants with certain malformations (265 with Down's syndrome, 396 with hypospadias, 146 with limb reduction defects, 116 with neoplasms, and 215 with neural-tube defects) were compared with 3442 control infants with a wide variety of other defects. Exposure to spermicides was assessed for three periods: use during the periconceptional period (one month before through one month after the last menstrual period), use during the first trimester (the first four lunar months of pregnancy), and any use during the lifetime. For the five groups of cases and for each interval, the odds ratios were close to 1.0 (range, 0.7 to 1.3); the upper 95 percent confidence bounds were 2.2 or lower. Risks did not increase with the duration of exposure. When each of the active ingredients in currently available spermicides was considered separately, no differences in odds ratios were apparent between the types of spermicides. With the possible exception of a subgroup of cases (limb reduction defects of unknown cause), these results suggest that risks for the five specific birth defects evaluated are not increased by exposure to spermicides.
多项研究发现,使用杀精剂与出生缺陷的总体发生率增加并无关联,但特定缺陷增加的可能性依然存在。我们在一项大型病例对照研究中评估了这种可能性。将患有某些畸形的婴儿(265例唐氏综合征、396例尿道下裂、146例肢体短小缺陷、116例肿瘤以及215例神经管缺陷)与3442例患有各种其他缺陷的对照婴儿进行比较。评估了三个时间段的杀精剂暴露情况:受孕期间(末次月经前1个月至末次月经后1个月)使用情况、孕早期(妊娠头四个农历月)使用情况以及一生中的任何使用情况。对于五组病例以及每个时间段,比值比均接近1.0(范围为0.7至1.3);95%置信区间上限为2.2或更低。风险并未随暴露时间延长而增加。当分别考虑目前可用杀精剂中的每种活性成分时,不同类型杀精剂之间的比值比并无明显差异。除了一个病例亚组(病因不明的肢体短小缺陷)可能存在例外情况外,这些结果表明,所评估的五种特定出生缺陷的风险不会因接触杀精剂而增加。