1 School of Earth and Space Exploration, Arizona State University , Tempe, Arizona.
2 NASA Astrobiology Institute , NASA Ames Research Center, Moffett Field, California.
Astrobiology. 2018 Mar;18(3):365-375. doi: 10.1089/ast.2017.1710.
Astrobiology is an inherently interdisciplinary area of study, demanding communication across multiple fields: astronomy, geochemistry, planetary science, and so on. Successful communication requires that researchers be aware of the basic findings, open questions, and tools and techniques of allied fields and possess an appreciation and respect for what these fields consider good science. To facilitate this communication between early-career researchers, the Arizona NExSS Winter School was hosted in February 2016, bringing together graduate students and postdoctoral researchers from backgrounds spanning the field of astrobiology. Students virtually attended a scientific Workshop Without Walls and participated in lectures, discussions, field trips, and hands-on activities, culminating in the writing and review of mock proposals by interdisciplinary teams. We assess the impact of the school on interdisciplinarity using a pre- and posttest survey of 24 students, informed by National Science Foundation impact categories (Friedman et al., 2008 ) within the Impact Analysis Method (IAM) described by Davis and Scalice ( 2015 ). We demonstrate that students gained knowledge, especially in fields outside their home discipline. Furthermore, an underlying disciplinary divide between geochemists and planetary scientists on the role of life in planetary evolution is observed and interpreted. These findings demonstrate that the Arizona NExSS Winter School had measurable impact on interdisciplinarity and that the IAM rubric has utility in measuring impact. We make recommendations for further research to understand the interdisciplinary gaps in astrobiology and how best to bridge them. Key Words: Interdisciplinarity-Attitudes-Knowledge-Scientific dialogue-Training. Astrobiology 18, 365-375.
天体生物学是一个固有的跨学科研究领域,需要在多个领域进行沟通:天文学、地球化学、行星科学等。成功的沟通要求研究人员了解相关领域的基本发现、悬而未决的问题以及工具和技术,并欣赏和尊重这些领域所认为的良好科学。为了促进早期职业研究人员之间的这种沟通,2016 年 2 月举办了亚利桑那州 NExSS 冬季学校,汇集了来自天体生物学领域的研究生和博士后研究人员。学生们远程参加了一个科学研讨会,并参加了讲座、讨论、实地考察和实践活动,最终由跨学科团队撰写和审查模拟提案。我们使用 24 名学生的预测试和后测试调查,根据国家科学基金会影响类别(Friedman 等人,2008 年),利用 Davis 和 Scalice(2015 年)描述的影响分析方法(IAM)来评估学校对跨学科性的影响。我们证明学生获得了知识,尤其是在他们的专业领域之外的领域。此外,观察到并解释了地球化学家与行星科学家之间在生命在行星演化中的作用方面的基本学科分歧。这些发现表明,亚利桑那州 NExSS 冬季学校对跨学科性有可衡量的影响,并且 IAM 纲要在衡量影响方面具有实用性。我们提出了进一步研究的建议,以了解天体生物学中的跨学科差距以及如何最好地弥合这些差距。关键词:跨学科性-态度-知识-科学对话-培训。天体生物学 18,365-375。