Frankel Jennifer, Wilén Jonna, Hansson Mild Kjell
Department of Radiation Sciences, Radiation Physics, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
Front Public Health. 2018 Mar 12;6:66. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2018.00066. eCollection 2018.
A complex mixture of electromagnetic fields is used in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI): static, low-frequency, and radio frequency magnetic fields. Commonly, the static magnetic field ranges from one to three Tesla. The low-frequency field can reach several millitesla and with a time derivative of the order of some Tesla per second. The radiofrequency (RF) field has a magnitude in the microtesla range giving rise to specific absorption rate values of a few Watts per kilogram. Very little attention has been paid to the case where there is a combined exposure to several different fields at the same time. Some studies have shown genotoxic effects in cells after exposure to an MRI scan while others have not demonstrated any effects. A typical MRI exam includes muliple imaging sequences of varying length and intensity, to produce different types of images. Each sequence is designed with a particular purpose in mind, so one sequence can, for example, be optimized for clearly showing fat water contrast, while another is optimized for high-resolution detail. It is of the utmost importance that future experimental studies give a thorough description of the exposure they are using, and not just a statement such as "An ordinary MRI sequence was used." Even if the sequence is specified, it can differ substantially between manufacturers on, e.g., RF pulse height, width, and duty cycle. In the latest SCENIHR opinion, it is stated that there is very little information regarding the health effects of occupational exposure to MRI fields, and long-term prospective or retrospective cohort studies on workers are recommended as a high priority. They also state that MRI is increasingly used in pediatric diagnostic imaging, and a cohort study into the effects of MRI exposure on children is recommended as a high priority. For the exposure assessment in epidemiological studies, there is a clear difference between patients and staff and further work is needed on this. Studies that explore the possible differences between MRI scan sequences and compare them in terms of exposure level are warranted.
磁共振成像(MRI)使用的是复杂的电磁场混合物:静磁场、低频磁场和射频磁场。通常,静磁场强度范围为1至3特斯拉。低频磁场可达几毫特斯拉,其时间导数约为每秒几特斯拉。射频(RF)场的强度在微特斯拉范围内,会产生每千克几瓦特的比吸收率值。人们很少关注同时暴露于几种不同场的情况。一些研究表明,细胞在接受MRI扫描后会产生遗传毒性效应,而另一些研究则未显示出任何效应。典型的MRI检查包括多个长度和强度各异的成像序列,以生成不同类型的图像。每个序列的设计都有特定目的,例如,一个序列可优化用于清晰显示脂肪-水对比度,而另一个序列则优化用于高分辨率细节显示。至关重要的是,未来的实验研究要对所使用的暴露情况进行全面描述,而不仅仅是诸如“使用了普通MRI序列”这样的表述。即使指定了序列,不同制造商的序列在例如射频脉冲高度、宽度和占空比等方面也可能有很大差异。在SCENIHR的最新意见中指出,关于职业暴露于MRI场对健康影响的信息非常少,建议将针对工人的长期前瞻性或回顾性队列研究作为高度优先事项。他们还指出,MRI在儿科诊断成像中的应用越来越多,建议将针对MRI暴露对儿童影响的队列研究作为高度优先事项。对于流行病学研究中的暴露评估,患者和工作人员之间存在明显差异,对此还需要进一步开展工作。有必要开展研究来探索MRI扫描序列之间的可能差异,并在暴露水平方面进行比较。