Marone Jane R, Thakkar Shivam C, Suliman Neveen, O'Neill Shannon I, Doubleday Alison F
Department of Kinesiology and Nutrition, University of Illinois-Chicago , Chicago, Illinois.
Department of Oral Medicine and Diagnostic Sciences, University of Illinois-Chicago , Chicago, Illinois.
Adv Physiol Educ. 2018 Jun 1;42(2):175-181. doi: 10.1152/advan.00097.2017.
Poor academic performance from extensive social media usage appears to be due to students' inability to multitask between distractions and academic work. However, the degree to which visually distracted students can acquire lecture information presented aurally is unknown. This study examined the ability of students visually distracted by social media to acquire information presented during a voice-over PowerPoint lecture, and to compare performance on examination questions derived from information presented aurally vs. that presented visually. Students ( n = 20) listened to a 42-min cardiovascular pathophysiology lecture containing embedded cartoons while taking notes. The experimental group ( n = 10) was visually, but not aurally, distracted by social media during times when cartoon information was presented, ~40% of total lecture time. Overall performance among distracted students on a follow-up, open-note quiz was 30% poorer than that for controls ( P < 0.001). When the modality of presentation (visual vs. aural) was compared, performance decreased on examination questions from information presented visually. However, performance on questions from information presented aurally was similar to that of controls. Our findings suggest the ability to acquire information during lecture may vary, depending on the degree of competition between the modalities of the distraction and the lecture presentation. Within the context of current literature, our findings also suggest that timing of the distraction relative to delivery of material examined affects performance more than total distraction time. Therefore, when delivering lectures, instructors should incorporate organizational cues and active learning strategies that assist students in maintaining focus and acquiring relevant information.
大量使用社交媒体导致学业成绩不佳,这似乎是因为学生无法在分心因素和学业任务之间进行多任务处理。然而,视觉上分心的学生获取听觉呈现的讲座信息的程度尚不清楚。本研究考察了因社交媒体而视觉分心的学生获取画外音PowerPoint讲座中呈现信息的能力,并比较了基于听觉呈现信息与视觉呈现信息的考试问题的表现。学生(n = 20)边听42分钟包含嵌入式卡通的心血管病理生理学讲座边做笔记。实验组(n = 10)在呈现卡通信息的时间段(约占讲座总时长的40%)受到社交媒体的视觉干扰,但未受到听觉干扰。在后续的开卷测验中,分心学生的总体表现比对照组差30%(P < 0.001)。当比较呈现方式(视觉与听觉)时,基于视觉呈现信息的考试问题的表现有所下降。然而,基于听觉呈现信息的问题的表现与对照组相似。我们的研究结果表明,在讲座期间获取信息的能力可能会有所不同,这取决于干扰方式与讲座呈现方式之间的竞争程度。在当前文献的背景下,我们的研究结果还表明,干扰相对于所考察材料呈现的时间安排对表现的影响大于总干扰时间。因此,在授课时,教师应采用有助于学生保持专注并获取相关信息的组织线索和主动学习策略。