Karriker-Jaffe Katherine J, Witbrodt Jane, Subbaraman Meenakshi S, Kaskutas Lee Ann
Alcohol Research Group, Public Health Institute, 6001 Shellmound Street, Suite 450 Emeryville, CA, USA.
Alcohol Alcohol. 2018 Jul 1;53(4):394-402. doi: 10.1093/alcalc/agy025.
We examined whether alcohol-dependent individuals with sustained substance use or psychiatric problems after completing treatment were more likely to experience low social status and whether continued help-seeking would improve outcomes.
Ongoing alcohol, drug and psychiatric problems after completing treatment were associated with increased odds of low social status (unemployment, unstable housing and/or living in high-poverty neighborhood) over 7 years. The impact of drug problems declined over time, and there were small, delayed benefits of AA attendance on social status.
Alcohol-dependent individuals sampled from public and private treatment programs (N = 491; 62% male) in Northern California were interviewed at treatment entry and 1, 3, 5 and 7 years later. Random effects models tested relationships between problem severity (alcohol, drug and psychiatric problems) and help-seeking (attending specialty alcohol/drug treatment and Alcoholics Anonymous, AA) with low social status (unemployment, unstable housing and/or living in a high-poverty neighborhood) over time.
The proportion of participants experiencing none of the indicators of low social status increased between baseline and the 1-year follow-up and remained stable thereafter. Higher alcohol problem scores and having any drug and/or psychiatric problems in the years after treatment were associated with increased odds of low social status over time. An interaction of drug problems with time indicated the impact of drug problems on social status declined over the 7-year period. Both treatment-seeking and AA attendance were associated with increased odds of low social status, although lagged models suggested there were small, delayed benefits of AA attendance on improved social status over time.
Specialty addiction treatment alone was not sufficient to have positive long-term impacts on social status and social integration of most alcohol-dependent people.
我们研究了在完成治疗后仍存在持续物质使用或精神问题的酒精依赖个体是否更有可能处于低社会地位,以及持续寻求帮助是否会改善结果。
完成治疗后持续存在的酒精、药物和精神问题与7年内处于低社会地位(失业、住房不稳定和/或生活在高贫困社区)的几率增加有关。药物问题的影响随时间下降,参加戒酒互助会(AA)对社会地位有微小的、延迟的益处。
从北加利福尼亚的公共和私人治疗项目中抽取的酒精依赖个体(N = 491;62%为男性)在治疗开始时以及1年、3年、5年和7年后接受访谈。随机效应模型测试了问题严重程度(酒精、药物和精神问题)和寻求帮助(参加专门的酒精/药物治疗和戒酒互助会,AA)与随时间推移的低社会地位(失业、住房不稳定和/或生活在高贫困社区)之间的关系。
在基线和1年随访之间,未经历任何低社会地位指标的参与者比例增加,此后保持稳定。治疗后几年中较高的酒精问题得分以及存在任何药物和/或精神问题与随时间推移处于低社会地位的几率增加有关。药物问题与时间的相互作用表明,在7年期间,药物问题对社会地位的影响下降。寻求治疗和参加AA都与处于低社会地位的几率增加有关,尽管滞后模型表明,随着时间的推移,参加AA对改善社会地位有微小的、延迟的益处。
仅靠专门的成瘾治疗不足以对大多数酒精依赖者的社会地位和社会融合产生积极的长期影响。