Nakamura Katsumasa, Konishi Kenta, Komatsu Tetsuya, Sasaki Tomonari, Shikama Naoto
Department of Radiation Oncology, Hamamatsu University School of Medicine, Hamamatsu.
Department of Health Sciences, Graduate School of Medical Sciences, Kyushu University, Fukuoka.
Jpn J Clin Oncol. 2018 May 1;48(5):476-479. doi: 10.1093/jjco/hyy031.
In high-income countries, the number of radiotherapy machine per population reaches a sufficient level. However, the patterns of infrastructure of radiotherapy in high-income countries are not well known.
Among 29 high-income countries with gross national income of $25,000 or more per capita, we selected 23 countries whose total number of newly diagnosed cancer patients in 2012 was reported in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Health Statistics 2017. The numbers of radiotherapy centers and teletherapy machines in each of these 23 countries were collected using the Dictionary of Radiotherapy Centers database.
The number of cancer patients per teletherapy machine was 452.35-1398.22 (median 711.66) with a three-fold variation, whereas the number of cancer patients per radiotherapy center varied even more widely, from 826.16 to 5159.86 (median 2259.83) with a six-fold variation. The average number of teletherapy machines per radiotherapy center also ranged widely, from 1.24 to 8.29 (median 3.11) with a seven-fold variation. The number of teletherapy machines in each country was almost proportional to that of cancer patients, and the number of teletherapy machines per radiotherapy center was inversely related to the number of radiotherapy centers per cancer patients. The number of teletherapy machines per radiotherapy center in Japan was 1.24, the most fragmented among the high-income countries. The percentage of large radiotherapy centers having three or more teletherapy machines in Japan was the smallest among 23 high-income countries.
Optimization of the radiotherapy infrastructure in Japan should be carefully considered.
在高收入国家,人均放疗设备数量已达到充足水平。然而,高收入国家放疗基础设施的模式尚不清楚。
在人均国民收入25,000美元及以上的29个高收入国家中,我们选取了23个国家,其2012年新诊断癌症患者总数在《经合组织2017年卫生统计》中有报告。这23个国家中每个国家的放疗中心数量和远距离治疗设备数量是通过放疗中心词典数据库收集的。
每台远距离治疗设备对应的癌症患者数量为452.35 - 1398.22(中位数711.66),有三倍的差异,而每个放疗中心对应的癌症患者数量差异更大,从826.16到5159.86(中位数2259.83),有六倍的差异。每个放疗中心的远距离治疗设备平均数量范围也很广,从1.24到8.29(中位数3.11),有七倍的差异。每个国家的远距离治疗设备数量几乎与癌症患者数量成正比,每个放疗中心的远距离治疗设备数量与每癌症患者的放疗中心数量呈负相关。日本每个放疗中心的远距离治疗设备数量为1.24,在高收入国家中是最分散的。在23个高收入国家中,日本拥有三台或更多远距离治疗设备的大型放疗中心所占百分比最小。
应认真考虑优化日本的放疗基础设施。