University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire NHS Trust, Coventry, UK.
Burton Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Burton-on-Trent, UK.
Anaesthesia. 2018 Jul;73(7):847-855. doi: 10.1111/anae.14289. Epub 2018 Apr 16.
Head and neck position is one of the factors which can be associated with difficult videolaryngoscopy and tracheal intubation. This prospective randomised clinical trial compared 'sniffing' and neutral positions using a channelled (KingVision ) and a non-channelled (C-MAC D-blade) videolaryngoscope in 200 adult patients randomly allocated into four groups (KingVision 'sniffing', KingVision neutral, C-MAC 'sniffing' and C-MAC neutral). The primary outcome was the ease of tracheal intubation using the modified intubation difficulty scale (mIDS) score. Laryngoscopy time, intubation time, laryngoscopic view using the percentage of glottic opening (POGO) score and success rate of tracheal intubation were secondary outcomes. The median (IQR [range]) modified difficulty scale scores for the four groups, respectively, were 0 (0-1 [0-3]), 0 (0-1 [0-4]), 1 (0-1 [0-5]) and 0 (0-1 [0-3]; p = 0.384). There was no significant difference in laryngoscopy time (p = 0.020), intubation time (p = 0.272) and success rate (p = 0.968) between the groups. The percentage of glottic opening score was lower for C-MAC neutral group as compared with other three groups (p = 0.01). There was no significant difference in the ease of intubation between the 'sniffing' and the neutral position when using the KingVision and the C-MAC videolaryngoscopes. Therefore, either of the two positions could be used with these types of videolaryngoscopes, if deemed advantageous for the patient.
头颈部位置是与困难喉镜检查和气管插管相关的因素之一。这项前瞻性随机临床试验比较了使用有通道(KingVision)和无通道(C-MAC D 刀片)可视喉镜的“嗅探”位和中立位在 200 例成年患者中的效果,这些患者被随机分为四组(KingVision“嗅探”位、KingVision 中立位、C-MAC“嗅探”位和 C-MAC 中立位)。主要结局是使用改良插管困难量表(mIDS)评分评估气管插管的难易程度。次要结局是喉镜检查时间、插管时间、使用声门显露百分比(POGO)评分的喉镜视图和气管插管成功率。四组的中位数(IQR[范围])改良困难量表评分分别为 0(0-1[0-3])、0(0-1[0-4])、1(0-1[0-5])和 0(0-1[0-3];p=0.384)。各组之间喉镜检查时间(p=0.020)、插管时间(p=0.272)和成功率(p=0.968)无显著差异。与其他三组相比,C-MAC 中立位的声门显露百分比较低(p=0.01)。使用 KingVision 和 C-MAC 可视喉镜时,“嗅探”位和中立位的插管难易程度无显著差异。因此,如果对患者有利,这两种位置都可以用于这两种类型的可视喉镜。