Lin W S, Chou J C, Charette J R, Metz M J, Harris B T, Choi N
Department of Prosthodontics, Indiana University School of Dentistry, Indianapolis, IN, USA.
Department of Restorative Clinical Sciences, School of Dentistry, University of Missouri-Kansas City, Kansas City, MO, USA.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2018 Aug;22(3):e573-e581. doi: 10.1111/eje.12354. Epub 2018 Apr 17.
This research aimed to evaluate the students' usage and perceptions of using smartphones in their general dental education and learning tooth preparation with the individually designed virtual 3D instructional models in the pre-clinical removable partial denture course.
Second-year dental students were asked to voluntarily participate in a survey to investigate their demographic information, general usages of smartphones, perception of smartphones usage in dental education (construct 1) and perception of individually designed virtual 3D instructional models (construct 2). Students' responses of general usages of the smartphones were compared with their demographic and educational backgrounds using nonparametric Kruskal-Wallis test (for age) and Fisher's exact test (for sex, race and educational background). The sums of scores of the construct 1 and construct 2 were tested for associations with student's demographic and educational backgrounds using the Pearson product-moment correlation (for age), t test (for sex and educational background) or one-way ANOVA F test (for race) (α = .05).
A 75% response rate (N = 90) was achieved in this study, and all 90 participants owned smartphones. Students' responses to general usages of the smartphones were not significantly influenced by their demographic background. For the construct 1, more than 73% of participants responded either agree or strongly agree to the usage of smartphones in general dental education and pre-clinical setting; however, only 49% of participants responded the same way in the clinical setting. For the construct 2, 48 of 90 participants viewed the 3D models, and more than 73% of these 48 participants responded either agree or strongly agree to the usage of the 3D models in the pre-clinical course. Student's demographic background did not have significant influence on the sums of scores of the construct 1 and construct 2.
Within the limitations of this study, high usages and ownerships of smartphones were found amongst the students surveyed. The individually designed virtual 3D instructional models as supplemental teaching materials in the pre-clinical course were perceived positively by the students.
本研究旨在评估学生在口腔修复临床前课程中使用智能手机的情况以及对使用智能手机结合个性化设计的虚拟3D教学模型进行全口义齿修复学习的看法。
邀请二年级牙科学生自愿参与一项调查,以了解他们的人口统计学信息、智能手机的一般使用情况、对智能手机在牙科教育中的使用看法(结构1)以及对个性化设计的虚拟3D教学模型的看法(结构2)。使用非参数Kruskal-Wallis检验(用于年龄)和Fisher精确检验(用于性别、种族和教育背景),将学生对智能手机一般使用情况的回答与其人口统计学和教育背景进行比较。使用Pearson积差相关(用于年龄)、t检验(用于性别和教育背景)或单因素方差分析F检验(用于种族)(α = 0.05),检验结构1和结构2得分总和与学生人口统计学和教育背景之间的相关性。
本研究的回复率为75%(N = 90),所有90名参与者都拥有智能手机。学生对智能手机一般使用情况的回答不受其人口统计学背景的显著影响。对于结构1,超过73%的参与者对智能手机在全口义齿修复临床前课程中的使用表示同意或强烈同意;然而,在临床环境中,只有49%的参与者给出了相同的回答。对于结构2,90名参与者中有48人查看了3D模型,这48名参与者中超过73%对3D模型在临床前课程中的使用表示同意或强烈同意。学生的人口统计学背景对结构1和结构2的得分总和没有显著影响。
在本研究的局限性范围内,调查的学生中智能手机的使用率和拥有率较高。学生对个性化设计的虚拟3D教学模型作为临床前课程补充教材的评价较好。