Rhoads Candace L, Miller Patricia H, Jaeger Gina O
Department of Psychology, San Francisco State University, San Francisco, CA 94132, United States.
Department of Psychology, San Francisco State University, San Francisco, CA 94132, United States.
J Exp Child Psychol. 2018 Sep;173:41-58. doi: 10.1016/j.jecp.2018.03.010. Epub 2018 Apr 17.
This study addressed the causal direction of a previously reported relation between preschoolers' gesturing and their executive functioning on the Dimensional Change Card Sort (DCCS) sorting-switch task. Gesturing the relevant dimension for sorting was induced in a Gesture group through instructions, imitation, and prompts. In contrast, the Control group was instructed to "think hard" when sorting. Preschoolers (N = 50) performed two DCCS tasks: (a) sort by size and then spatial orientation of two objects and (b) sort by shape and then proximity of the two objects. An examination of performance over trials permitted a fine-grained depiction of patterns of younger and older children in the Gesture and Control conditions. After the relevant dimension was switched, the Gesture group had more accurate sorts than the Control group, particularly among younger children on the second task. Moreover, the amount of gesturing predicted the number of correct sorts among younger children on the second task. The overall association between gesturing and sorting was not reflected at the level of individual trials, perhaps indicating covert gestural representation on some trials or the triggering of a relevant verbal representation by the gesturing. The delayed benefit of gesturing, until the second task, in the younger children may indicate a utilization deficiency. Results are discussed in terms of theories of gesturing and thought. The findings open up a new avenue of research and theorizing about the possible role of gesturing in emerging executive function.
本研究探讨了先前报道的学龄前儿童手势与他们在维度变化卡片分类任务(DCCS)中的执行功能之间关系的因果方向。通过指令、模仿和提示,在手势组中诱导出与分类相关的维度的手势。相比之下,对照组在分类时被要求“努力思考”。学龄前儿童(N = 50)完成了两项DCCS任务:(a)按大小然后按两个物体的空间方向进行分类,以及(b)按形状然后按两个物体的接近程度进行分类。对各次试验的表现进行检查,可以对处于手势条件和对照条件下的年幼儿童和年长儿童的模式进行细致的描述。在相关维度切换后,手势组的分类比对照组更准确,特别是在第二项任务中的年幼儿童中。此外,手势的数量预测了第二项任务中年幼儿童正确分类的数量。手势与分类之间的总体关联在个别试验层面并未体现,这可能表明在某些试验中存在隐蔽的手势表征,或者手势触发了相关的言语表征。年幼儿童直到第二项任务时手势才产生益处,这可能表明存在运用缺陷。研究结果根据手势和思维理论进行了讨论。这些发现为关于手势在新兴执行功能中可能作用的研究和理论化开辟了一条新途径。