VITO, 200 Boeretang, 2400 Mol, Belgium; University of Antwerp, Department of Bioengineering, Groenenborgerlaan 171, 2020 Antwerp, Belgium.
OVAM - Public Waste Agency of Flanders, ELFM-division, Stationsstraat 110, 2800 Mechelen, Belgium.
Waste Manag. 2018 Jul;77:225-237. doi: 10.1016/j.wasman.2018.03.049. Epub 2018 May 15.
This study aims at showing how the United Nations Framework Classification for Resources (UNFC) can help to classify potential landfill mining projects with different levels of maturity, from exploration to production, under technical, socio-economic and project-planning aspects. Taking the example of three former landfill sites in Flanders general decision making guidelines regarding the future management of old landfills are provided. Using the ECLAR methodology for the evaluation (E) and classification (CL) of anthropogenic resources (AR), the individual projects, where clean land and/or materials are recovered, are mapped under the three-dimensional UNFC system. The Bornem project, yields a negative Net Present Value (NPV) of -17 Mio € (-44 €/t of excavated waste), i.e. the project is currently not economically viable. In case of changing key parameters the landfill has, however, reasonable prospects for future economic extraction. The Turnhout land development turned out to be economically viable with a NPV of 361,000 € (8 €/t of excavated waste). The Zuienkerke remediation project is at a too early stage to determine its socioeconomic viability. The main focus to compare and prioritize potential landfill mining projects in Flanders should be on (1) site specific conditions (e.g. landfill's composition, land prices), (2) project related factors (e.g. remediation required vs. resource/land recovery, selected technologies and project set-ups, private vs. public evaluation perspective) and (3) the timing of mining, considering future development of costs, prices, laws, available data and information.
本研究旨在展示联合国资源分类框架(UNFC)如何帮助对不同成熟度的潜在垃圾填埋场开采项目进行分类,从勘探到生产,涉及技术、社会经济和项目规划等方面。以弗拉芒地区的三个前垃圾填埋场为例,提供了关于旧垃圾填埋场未来管理的总体决策指导方针。使用 ECLAR 方法对人为资源(AR)进行评估(E)和分类(CL),将单独的项目(在这些项目中回收清洁土地和/或材料)映射到三维 UNFC 系统下。博恩姆项目的净现值(NPV)为-1700 万欧元(挖掘废物每吨-44 欧元),即该项目目前在经济上不可行。然而,如果改变垃圾填埋场的关键参数,该填埋场仍有合理的未来经济开采前景。特恩豪特土地开发项目的经济可行性净现值为 36.1 万欧元(挖掘废物每吨 8 欧元)。祖因克尔克修复项目处于早期阶段,无法确定其社会经济效益。在弗拉芒地区比较和优先考虑潜在垃圾填埋场开采项目的主要重点应放在(1)特定地点的条件(例如,垃圾填埋场的组成、土地价格)、(2)与项目相关的因素(例如,修复所需与资源/土地回收、选定的技术和项目设置、私人与公共评估视角)以及(3)开采时间,考虑到未来成本、价格、法律、可用数据和信息的发展。