Ghent University.
Radboud University Nijmegen.
J Cogn Neurosci. 2018 Aug;30(8):1170-1184. doi: 10.1162/jocn_a_01270. Epub 2018 Apr 25.
Verbal instructions are central to humans' capacity to learn new behaviors with minimal training, but the neurocognitive mechanisms involved in verbally instructed behaviors remain puzzling. Recent functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) evidence suggests that the right middle frontal gyrus and dorsal premotor cortex (rMFG-dPMC) supports the translation of symbolic stimulus-response mappings into sensorimotor representations. Here, we set out to (1) replicate this finding, (2) investigate whether this region's involvement is specific to novel (vs. trained) instructions, and (3) study whether rMFG-dPMC also shows differences in its (voxel) pattern response indicative of general cognitive processes of instruction implementation. Participants were shown instructions, which they either had to perform later or merely memorize. Orthogonal to this manipulation, the instructions were either entirely novel or had been trained before the fMRI session. Results replicate higher rMFG-dPMC activation levels during instruction implementation versus memorization and show how this difference is restricted to novel, but not trained, instruction presentations. Pattern similarity analyses at the voxel level further reveal more consistent neural pattern responses in rMFG-dPMC during the implementation of novel versus trained instructions. In fact, this more consistent neural pattern response seemed to be specific to the first instruction presentation and disappeared after the instruction had been applied once. These results further support a role of rMFG-dPMC in the implementation of novel task instructions and highlight potentially important differences in studying this region's gross activation levels versus (the consistency of) its response patterns.
口头指令是人类用最少的训练学习新行为的能力的核心,但涉及到口头指导行为的神经认知机制仍然令人费解。最近的功能磁共振成像(fMRI)证据表明,右额中回和背侧运动前皮层(rMFG-dPMC)支持将符号刺激-反应映射转化为感觉运动表示。在这里,我们着手(1)复制这一发现,(2)研究该区域的参与是否特定于新的(与训练过的)指令,以及(3)研究 rMFG-dPMC 是否在其(体素)模式反应上也存在差异,这些差异表明指令实施的一般认知过程。参与者被展示了指令,他们要么稍后执行,要么只是记住。与这种操作正交的是,指令要么完全是新的,要么在 fMRI 会议之前已经经过训练。结果复制了在执行指令时比记忆时 rMFG-dPMC 更高的激活水平,并表明这种差异仅限于新的指令,而不是训练过的指令。在体素水平上的模式相似性分析进一步揭示了 rMFG-dPMC 在执行新的指令与训练过的指令时更一致的神经模式反应。事实上,这种更一致的神经模式反应似乎是新指令呈现的特异性,并且在指令被应用一次后就消失了。这些结果进一步支持 rMFG-dPMC 在新任务指令执行中的作用,并突出了研究该区域的总体激活水平与(其反应模式的)一致性之间可能存在的重要差异。