Feldman Brian M, Rivard Georges E, Babyn Paul, Wu John K M, Steele MacGregor, Poon Man-Chiu, Card Robert T, Israels Sara J, Laferriere Nicole, Gill Kulwant, Chan Anthony K, Carcao Manuel, Klaassen Robert J, Cloutier Stephanie, Price Victoria E, Dover Saunya, Blanchette Victor S
Division of Rheumatology, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, ON, Canada; Child Health Evaluative Sciences, The Hospital for Sick Children Research Institute, Toronto, ON, Canada; Department of Pediatrics, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada; Institute of Health Policy, Management & Evaluation, the Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Division of Hematology/Oncology, Department of Pediatrics, CHU Sainte-Justine, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Lancet Haematol. 2018 Jun;5(6):e252-e260. doi: 10.1016/S2352-3026(18)30048-6. Epub 2018 May 3.
Severe haemophilia A has high morbidity, and treatment, while effective, is very expensive. We report the 16-year follow-up of the Canadian Hemophilia Prophylaxis Study, which examined the effectiveness of tailored frequency-escalated primary prophylaxis with a focus on health outcomes within the domains of body structures and functions, and activities and participation (according to the WHO International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health [WHO-ICF] framework) and a view to reducing consumption of costly clotting factor, which accounts for more than 90% of the cost of care of severe haemophilia.
In this longitudinal study, boys with severe haemophilia A from 12 Canadian centres were enrolled at age 1·0-2·5 years. They were treated with standard half-life recombinant factor VIII (SHL-rFVIII), beginning as once-weekly prophylaxis with 50 IU/kg and escalating in frequency (with accompanying dose adjustments) in response to breakthrough bleeding as determined by the protocol. The primary endpoint for this analysis was joint health, as measured by the modified Colorado Child Physical Examination Scores (CCPES) at study end. All analyses were done by intention to treat. The trial is complete, and is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT01085344.
Between June 26, 1997, and Jan 30, 2007, 56 boys were enrolled. They were followed for a median of 10·2 years (to a maximum of 16·1 years). Median rFVIII usage was about 3600 IU/kg per year. The median end-of-study CCPES physical examination score was 1 (IQR 1-3; range 0-12) for the left ankle and 1 (1-2; 0-12) for the right ankle, with all other joints having a median score of 0. No treatment-related safety events occurred over the duration of the study, including central venous catheter infections. The median annualised index joint bleeding rate was 0·95 per year (IQR 0·44-1·35; range 0·00-13·43), but 17 (30%) patients had protocol-defined unacceptable breakthrough bleeding at some point during the study.
Tailored frequency-escalated prophylaxis leads to very little arthropathy and very good health outcomes within the WHO-ICF domains, and only uses a moderate amount of expensive clotting factor as compared with standard prophylaxis protocols. Some sequelae of bleeding were observed in our cohort, and future studies should consider a more stringent protocol of escalation.
This study was initially funded by grants from the Medical Research Council of Canada/Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association of Canada Partnership Fund and the Bayer/Canadian Blood Services/Hema-Quebec Partnership Fund. Subsequent renewals were funded by Bayer.
重度甲型血友病发病率高,其治疗虽有效果,但费用高昂。我们报告了加拿大血友病预防研究的16年随访结果,该研究考察了量身定制的频率递增初级预防方案的有效性,重点关注身体结构与功能、活动与参与等领域的健康结局(根据世界卫生组织《国际功能、残疾和健康分类》[WHO-ICF]框架),旨在减少昂贵凝血因子的消耗,凝血因子费用占重度血友病治疗费用的90%以上。
在这项纵向研究中,来自加拿大12个中心的重度甲型血友病男孩于1.0 - 2.5岁时入组。他们接受标准半衰期重组凝血因子VIII(SHL-rFVIII)治疗,开始时每周一次预防用药,剂量为50 IU/kg,并根据方案确定的突破性出血情况增加用药频率(同时调整剂量)。该分析的主要终点是研究结束时通过改良科罗拉多儿童体格检查评分(CCPES)衡量的关节健康状况。所有分析均按意向性分析进行。该试验已完成,并在ClinicalTrials.gov上注册,注册号为NCT01085344。
1997年6月26日至2007年1月30日期间,56名男孩入组。他们的中位随访时间为10.2年(最长16.1年)。重组凝血因子VIII的中位年使用量约为3600 IU/kg/年。研究结束时,左踝关节CCPES体格检查评分的中位数为1(四分位间距1 - 3;范围0 - 12),右踝关节为1(1 - 2;0 - 12),其他所有关节的评分中位数为0。在研究期间未发生与治疗相关的安全事件,包括中心静脉导管感染事件。年化指数关节出血率的中位数为每年0.95次(四分位间距0.44 - 1.35;范围0.00 - 13.43),但17名(30%)患者在研究期间的某些时间点出现了方案定义的不可接受的突破性出血情况发生。
量身定制的频率递增预防方案导致关节病极少,在WHO-ICF领域内健康结局良好,与标准预防方案相比,仅使用了适量的昂贵凝血因子。在我们的队列中观察到了一些出血后遗症,未来研究应考虑采用更严格的递增方案。
本研究最初由加拿大医学研究理事会/加拿大制药商协会合作基金以及拜耳/加拿大血液服务机构/魁北克血友病协会合作基金提供资助。后续的资助由拜耳公司提供。