Nondela Babalwa B, Cox Sharon G, Brink Anita, Millar Alastair J W, Numanoglu Alp
Division of Paediatric Surgery, Red Cross War Memorial Children's Hospital, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa.
Division of Nuclear Medicine, Red Cross War Memorial Children's Hospital, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa.
Pediatr Surg Int. 2018 Jul;34(7):781-788. doi: 10.1007/s00383-018-4276-7. Epub 2018 May 14.
To determine a correlation between the 99mTc sucralfate scan and the endoscopy findings in children with caustic oesophageal injury.
This is an observational analytic study of children who had both 99mTc sucralfate scan and endoscopy after caustic substance ingestion at our institution in a period between January 2009 and September 2016. The oesophageal injury was classified into low grade and high grade according to the degree of adhesion on 99mTc sucralfate scan and modification of Zargar endoscopic grading.
Out of a total of 197 children, 40 children were identified who had both investigations done on average 26 h post-injury. Low-grade adhesion on 99mTc sucralfate scan was found in 27 children (68%), and all had low-grade Zargar's oesophageal injuries. None of these subsequently developed residual pathology. Thirteen had high-grade adhesion and five of these had high-grade injury on endoscopy. Three (23%) developed oesophageal strictures. Correlation of 99mTc sucralfate and endoscopic findings reached statistical significance with a p value of 0.0014. No morbidity was associated with either the scan or endoscopy.
We concluded that low-grade sucralfate scan finding has the potential to successfully eliminate the need for invasive endoscopy under general anaesthesia and thereby reducing procedure-related morbidity, hospitalization and associated costs. However, mandatory endoscopy is required in children with high-grade adhesion seen on 99mTc sucralfate scan. This requires confirmation using a larger prospective study.
确定99m锝硫糖铝扫描与腐蚀性食管损伤患儿内镜检查结果之间的相关性。
这是一项对2009年1月至2016年9月期间在我院摄入腐蚀性物质后同时进行99m锝硫糖铝扫描和内镜检查的患儿进行的观察性分析研究。根据99m锝硫糖铝扫描的粘连程度和Zargar内镜分级的改变,将食管损伤分为低度和高度。
在总共197名儿童中,确定有40名儿童在受伤后平均26小时进行了两项检查。27名儿童(68%)的99m锝硫糖铝扫描显示低度粘连,且所有这些儿童的Zargar食管损伤均为低度。这些儿童随后均未出现残留病变。13名儿童有高度粘连,其中5名在内镜检查时有高度损伤。3名(23%)出现食管狭窄。99m锝硫糖铝扫描与内镜检查结果的相关性具有统计学意义,p值为0.0014。扫描或内镜检查均未导致任何并发症。
我们得出结论,低度硫糖铝扫描结果有可能成功消除全身麻醉下侵入性内镜检查的必要性,从而降低与手术相关的发病率、住院时间和相关费用。然而,99m锝硫糖铝扫描显示高度粘连的儿童需要进行强制性内镜检查。这需要通过更大规模的前瞻性研究来证实。