Pasiali Varvara, Clark Cherie
Queens University of Charlotte.
J Music Ther. 2018 Sep 8;55(3):280-308. doi: 10.1093/jmt/thy007.
Children living in low-resource communities are at risk for poorer socio-emotional development and academic performance. Emerging evidence supports use of group music therapy experiences to support social development through community afterschool programming.
To examine the potential benefit of a music therapy social skills development program to improve social skills and academic performance of school-aged children with limited resources in an afterschool program.
We used a single-group pre/post-test design, and recruited 20 students (11 females, 9 males), ages 5 to 11 years, from an afterschool program. The music therapy social skills program consisted of eight 50-minute sessions, and we measured social competence and antisocial behavior using the Home & Community Social Behavioral Scale (HCSBS; Merrell & Caldarella, 2008), and social skills, problem behaviors, and academic competence using the Social Skills Improvement System (SSIS; Gresham & Elliot, 2008a, 2008b).
Only students who attended a minimum of six sessions (N = 14) were included in data analysis. Results showed no significant change in individual HBSC subscale scores; however, the total number of low-performance/high-risk skills significantly decreased. SSIS teacher results indicated significant improvement in communication, significant decrease of hyperactivity, autistic behavioral tendencies and overall problem behaviors, and marginal decreases in internalization. Parent ratings mirrored, in part, those of the teacher.
Results indicated that music therapy has the potential of being an effective intervention for promoting social competence of school-aged children with limited resources, particularly in the areas of communication and low-performance/high-risk behaviors. Teaching skills through song lyrics and improvisation emerged as salient interventions.
生活在资源匮乏社区的儿童在社会情感发展和学业成绩方面面临较差表现的风险。新出现的证据支持通过社区课外项目利用集体音乐治疗体验来促进社会发展。
考察音乐治疗社交技能发展项目对提高参加课外项目的资源有限的学龄儿童社交技能和学业成绩的潜在益处。
我们采用单组前后测设计,从一个课外项目中招募了20名学生(11名女生,9名男生),年龄在5至11岁之间。音乐治疗社交技能项目包括8节时长50分钟的课程,我们使用家庭与社区社会行为量表(HCSBS;梅里尔和卡尔德拉雷拉,2008年)测量社交能力和反社会行为,使用社交技能改进系统(SSIS;格雷沙姆和埃利奥特,2008a,2008b)测量社交技能、问题行为和学业能力。
数据分析仅纳入了至少参加6节课程的学生(N = 14)。结果显示,HBSC各分量表得分无显著变化;然而,低表现/高风险技能的总数显著减少。SSIS教师评估结果表明,沟通能力有显著提高,多动、自闭症行为倾向和总体问题行为显著减少,内化问题有轻微减少。家长评分部分反映了教师的评分。
结果表明,音乐治疗有可能成为促进资源有限的学龄儿童社交能力的有效干预措施,特别是在沟通以及低表现/高风险行为领域。通过歌曲歌词和即兴创作来教授技能是突出的干预方式。