Institute of Public Safety Research, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China.
Liverpool Business School, Liverpool John Moores University, Liverpool, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2018 May 24;13(5):e0197125. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0197125. eCollection 2018.
China's fast economic growth contributes to the rapid development of its urbanization process, and also renders a series of industrial accidents, which often cause loss of life, damage to property and environment, thus requiring the associated risk analysis and safety control measures to be implemented in advance. However, incompleteness of historical failure data before the occurrence of accidents makes it difficult to use traditional risk analysis approaches such as probabilistic risk analysis in many cases. This paper aims to develop a new methodology capable of assessing regional industrial safety (RIS) in an uncertain environment. A hierarchical structure for modelling the risks influencing RIS is first constructed. The hybrid of evidential reasoning (ER) and Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) is then used to assess the risks in a complementary way, in which AHP is hired to evaluate the weight of each risk factor and ER is employed to synthesise the safety evaluations of the investigated region(s) against the risk factors from the bottom to the top level in the hierarchy. The successful application of the hybrid approach in a real case analysis of RIS in several major districts of Beijing (capital of China) demonstrates its feasibility as well as provides risk analysts and safety engineers with useful insights on effective solutions to comprehensive risk assessment of RIS in metropolitan cities. The contribution of this paper is made by the findings on the comparison of risk levels of RIS at different regions against various risk factors so that best practices from the good performer(s) can be used to improve the safety of the others.
中国经济的快速增长促进了城市化进程的快速发展,但也导致了一系列工业事故,这些事故经常造成生命损失、财产和环境破坏,因此需要提前进行相关的风险分析和安全控制措施。然而,在事故发生之前,历史故障数据的不完整性使得在许多情况下难以使用传统的风险分析方法,如概率风险分析。本文旨在开发一种新的方法,能够在不确定的环境中评估区域工业安全(RIS)。首先构建了一个用于建模影响 RIS 的风险的层次结构。然后,采用证据推理(ER)和层次分析法(AHP)的混合方法来互补地评估风险,其中 AHP 用于评估每个风险因素的权重,而 ER 用于从层次结构的底层到顶层综合调查区域对风险因素的安全评估。该混合方法在北京(中国首都)几个主要城区的 RIS 实际案例分析中的成功应用证明了其可行性,并为风险分析师和安全工程师提供了有关大都市 RIS 综合风险评估的有效解决方案的有用见解。本文的贡献在于比较了不同地区对各种风险因素的 RIS 风险水平的差异,以便从表现良好的地区(或地区)中吸取最佳实践,提高其他地区的安全性。