Pellegrini José Augusto Santos, Cordioli Ricardo Luiz, Grumann Ana Cristina Burigo, Ziegelmann Patrícia Klarmann, Taniguchi Leandro Utino
Department of Critical Care Medicine, Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, Brazil.
Department of Critical Care Medicine, Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein, São Paulo, Brazil.
Ann Intensive Care. 2018 Apr 20;8(1):50. doi: 10.1186/s13613-018-0397-3.
Point-of-care ultrasonography (POCUS) has recently become a useful tool that intensivists are incorporating into clinical practice. However, the incorporation of ultrasonography in critical care in developing countries is not straightforward.
Our objective was to investigate current practice and education regarding POCUS among Brazilian intensivists. A national survey was administered to Brazilian intensivists using an electronic questionnaire. Questions were selected by the Delphi method and assessed topics included organizational issues, POCUS technique and training patterns, machine availability, and main applications of POCUS in daily practice.
Of 1533 intensivists who received the questionnaire, 322 responded from all of Brazil's regions. Two hundred and five (63.8%) reported having access to an ultrasound machine dedicated to the intensive care unit (ICU); however, this was more likely in university hospitals than in non-university hospitals (80.6 vs. 59.6%; risk ratio [RR] = 1.35 [1.16-1.58], p = 0.002). The main applications of POCUS were ultrasound-guided central vein catheterization (49.4%) and bedside echocardiographic assessment (33.9%). Two hundred and fifty-eight (80.0%) reported having at least one POCUS-trained intensivist in their staff (trained units). Trained units were more likely to perform routine ultrasound-guided jugular vein catheterization than non-trained units (38.6 vs. 16.4%; RR = 2.35 [1.31-4.23], p = 0.001). The proportion of POCUS-trained intensivists and availability of a dedicated ultrasound machine were both independently associated with performing ultrasound-guided jugular vein catheterization (RR = 1.91 [1.32-2.77], p = 0.001) and (RR = 2.20 [1.26-3.29], p = 0.005), respectively.
A significant proportion of Brazilian ICUs had at least one intensivist with POCUS capability in their staff. Although ultrasound-guided central vein catheterization constitutes the main application of POCUS, adherence to guideline recommendations is still suboptimal.
床旁超声检查(POCUS)最近已成为重症监护医生纳入临床实践的一种有用工具。然而,在发展中国家将超声检查纳入重症监护并非易事。
我们的目的是调查巴西重症监护医生中关于POCUS的当前实践和教育情况。使用电子问卷对巴西重症监护医生进行了全国性调查。问题通过德尔菲法选择,评估的主题包括组织问题、POCUS技术和培训模式、机器可用性以及POCUS在日常实践中的主要应用。
在收到问卷的1533名重症监护医生中,有322人从巴西所有地区回复。205人(63.8%)报告可以使用专门用于重症监护病房(ICU)的超声机器;然而在大学医院比在非大学医院更有可能(80.6%对59.6%;风险比[RR]=1.35[1.16 - 1.58],p = 0.002)。POCUS的主要应用是超声引导下中心静脉置管(49.4%)和床旁超声心动图评估(33.9%)。258人(80.0%)报告其工作人员中有至少一名接受过POCUS培训的重症监护医生(经过培训的单位)。经过培训的单位比未经过培训的单位更有可能进行常规超声引导下颈静脉置管(38.6%对16.4%;RR = 2.35[1.31 - 4.23],p = 0.001)。接受过POCUS培训的重症监护医生比例和专用超声机器的可用性分别与进行超声引导下颈静脉置管独立相关(RR = 1.91[1.32 - 2.77],p = 0.001)和(RR = 2.20[1.26 - 3.29],p = 0.005)。
相当比例的巴西ICU工作人员中有至少一名具备POCUS能力的重症监护医生。尽管超声引导下中心静脉置管是POCUS 的主要应用,但对指南建议的遵循情况仍不理想。