Vrentas Catherine E, Adler Jacob J, Kleinschmit Adam J, Massimelli Julia
The Engaged Scientist, Ames, IA, 50014.
Division of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, Brescia University, Owensboro, KY, 42301.
J Microbiol Biol Educ. 2018 May 25;19(2). doi: 10.1128/jmbe.v19i2.1501. eCollection 2018.
American Society for Microbiology (ASM) Curriculum Guidelines highlight the importance of instruction about informational flow in organisms, including regulation of gene expression. However, foundational central dogma concepts and more advanced gene regulatory mechanisms are challenging for undergraduate biology students. To increase student comprehension of these principles, we designed an activity for upper-level biology students centered on construction and analysis of physical models of bacterial riboswitches. Students manipulate an inexpensive bag of supplies (beads, pipe cleaners) to model two conformations of a riboswitch in a bacterial transcript. After initial pilot testing, we implemented the activity in three upper-level classes at one research-intensive and two primarily undergraduate institutions. To assess student perceptions of learning gains, we utilized a pre/post-activity 5-point Likert-type survey instrument to characterize student perceptions of confidence in both their understanding of riboswitches and their ability to apply the central dogma to riboswitches. Median post-test ranks were significantly higher than median pre-test ranks ( < 0.0001) when compared by the Wilcoxon signed-rank test ( = 31). Next, we assessed post-activity knowledge via use of a rubric to score student responses on exam questions. More than 80% of students could correctly describe and diagram examples of riboswitches; data from initial iterations were used to enhance curriculum materials for subsequent implementations. We conclude that this riboswitch activity leads to both student-reported increases in confidence in the ASM curriculum dimension of gene regulation, including central dogma concepts, and demonstrated student ability to diagram riboswitches, predict outcomes of riboswitches, and connect riboswitches to evolutionary roles.
美国微生物学会(ASM)课程指南强调了讲授生物体信息流(包括基因表达调控)的重要性。然而,基础的中心法则概念和更高级的基因调控机制对于本科生物学学生来说具有挑战性。为了提高学生对这些原理的理解,我们为高年级生物学学生设计了一项活动,该活动围绕细菌核糖开关物理模型的构建和分析展开。学生们操作一袋价格低廉的材料(珠子、管道清洁器)来模拟细菌转录本中核糖开关的两种构象。经过初步试点测试后,我们在一所研究密集型机构和两所主要的本科院校的三个高年级班级中开展了这项活动。为了评估学生对学习收获的看法,我们使用了活动前/后的五点李克特式调查工具,以描述学生对理解核糖开关的信心以及将中心法则应用于核糖开关的能力的看法。通过威尔科克森符号秩检验(n = 31)比较时,测试后中位数排名显著高于测试前中位数排名(< 0.0001)。接下来,我们通过使用评分标准对学生考试问题的回答进行评分来评估活动后的知识掌握情况。超过80%的学生能够正确描述和绘制核糖开关的示例;初始迭代的数据被用于改进后续实施的课程材料。我们得出结论,这项核糖开关活动既使学生报告对包括中心法则概念在内的ASM课程基因调控维度的信心有所增加,又证明了学生有能力绘制核糖开关、预测核糖开关的结果,并将核糖开关与进化作用联系起来。