Department of Psychiatry, McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
Department of Mental Health, Bloomberg School of Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, USA.
J Public Health (Oxf). 2019 Mar 1;41(1):e35-e43. doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdy096.
Scant evidence exists on the relation between the availability of health professionals and adolescent health, and whether the size of the health workforce equally benefits adolescents across socioeconomic strata.
We conducted a cross-sectional analysis of adolescent health in 38 countries. Data from 218 790 adolescents were drawn from the 2013/2014 Health Behavior in School-aged Children survey. We used multilevel regression analyses to examine the association between the density of the health workforce and psychosomatic and mental health symptoms with differences in country wealth and income inequality controlled.
A higher density of psychologists was associated with better self-reported mental health in adolescents (P = 0.047); however, this finding was not robust to sensitivity analyses. The densities of physicians and psychiatrists were not significantly associated with better adolescent psychosomatic or mental health. Cross-level interactions between the health workforce and socioeconomic status did not relate to health, indicating that larger health workforces did not reduce socioeconomic differences in adolescent health.
This study found that adolescents in countries with a higher density of health providers do not report better psychosomatic or mental health. Other social or structural factors may play larger roles in adolescent health.
关于卫生专业人员的可及性与青少年健康之间的关系,以及卫生劳动力的规模是否同样有利于社会经济阶层不同的青少年,相关证据有限。
我们对 38 个国家的青少年健康进行了横断面分析。来自 218790 名青少年的数据来自于 2013/2014 年《在校儿童健康行为》调查。我们使用多水平回归分析来检验卫生劳动力密度与青少年身心症状之间的关联,同时控制了国家财富和收入不平等的差异。
较高的心理学家密度与青少年自我报告的心理健康状况较好相关(P=0.047);然而,这一发现经敏感性分析后并不稳健。医生和精神科医生的密度与青少年身心健康状况的改善没有显著关联。卫生劳动力与社会经济地位之间的交叉层次相互作用与健康无关,表明更大的卫生劳动力并没有减少青少年健康方面的社会经济差异。
本研究发现,卫生服务提供者密度较高的国家的青少年报告的身心症状或心理健康状况并没有改善。其他社会或结构性因素可能在青少年健康中发挥更大的作用。