School of Engineering, Department of Environmental Engineering, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran.
Department of Civil Engineering, Boise State University, Boise, USA.
Water Res. 2018 Oct 15;143:218-228. doi: 10.1016/j.watres.2018.06.050. Epub 2018 Jun 26.
Optimization-based deployment of contamination warning system in water distribution systems has been widely used in the literature, due to their superior performance compared to rule- and opinion-based approaches. However, optimization techniques impose an excessive computational burden, which in turn is compensated for by shrinking the problem's decision space and/or using faster optimization algorithms with less accuracy. This imposes subjectivity in interpretation of the system and associated risks, and undermines model's accuracy by not exploring the entire feasible space. We propose a framework that uses information theoretic techniques, including value of information and transinformation entropy, for optimal sensor placement. This can be used either as pre-selection, i.e. pinpointing best potential locations of sensors to be in turn used in optimization framework, or ultimate selection, i.e. single-handedly selecting sensor locations from the feasible space. The proposed framework is then applied to Lamerd water distribution system, in Fars province, Iran, and the results are compared to the suggested potential locations of sensors in previous studies and results of TEVA-SPOT model. The proposed information theoretic scheme enhances the decision space, provides more accurate results, significantly reduces the computational burden, and warrants objective selection of sensor placement.
基于优化的水污染预警系统在配水系统中的部署在文献中得到了广泛应用,因为与基于规则和经验的方法相比,它们具有更好的性能。然而,优化技术会带来过高的计算负担,这可以通过缩小问题的决策空间和/或使用更精确但速度较慢的优化算法来弥补。这会导致对系统及其相关风险的解释带有主观性,并通过不探索整个可行空间来降低模型的准确性。我们提出了一个使用信息论技术的框架,包括信息价值和转换信息熵,用于优化传感器的放置。该框架既可以作为预选择,即确定传感器的最佳潜在位置,然后再在优化框架中使用;也可以作为最终选择,即从可行空间中独立选择传感器位置。然后,将该框架应用于伊朗法尔斯省的拉默德配水系统,并将结果与先前研究中建议的传感器潜在位置以及 TEVA-SPOT 模型的结果进行比较。所提出的信息论方案增强了决策空间,提供了更准确的结果,显著降低了计算负担,并保证了传感器位置的客观选择。