Wang Yi-Zhen, Zhang Shi-Lu, Kong Fan-Qing, Yuan Yuan
Haihe River Water Environmental Monitoring Center, Tianjin 300170, China.
Key Laboratory of Pollution Processes and Environmental Criteria(Nankai University), Ministry of Education, Tianjin 300071, China.
Huan Jing Ke Xue. 2017 Oct 8;38(10):4194-4211. doi: 10.13227/j.hjkx.201703107.
Occurrence of 17 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and 15 persistent organochlorine pesticides (OCPs) were analyzed by gas chromatography coupled to tandem mass spectrometry (GC/MS/MS) during the spring and summer of 2015 in surface water at 14 sampling sites in the mainstream of the Luanhe River to elucidate their seasonal distribution, composition, and potential sources. Results showed that total PAH concentrations in the surface water of the Luanhe River ranged from 33.33 ng·L to 90.65 ng·L(52.64 ng·L in average) in spring and 147.68 ng·L to 252.68 ng·L (169.88 ng·L in average) in summer, respectively, and total concentrations of OCPs ranged from <0.08 ng·L to 3.48 ng·L (1.19 ng·L in average) in spring and <0.08 to 5.47 ng·L(1.02 ng·L in average) in summer, respectively. Seasonal pollution characteristics of PAHs in surface water during two different seasons showed that total PAH concentrations were much higher in summer than in spring at each sampling site on the Luanhe River. While seasonal pollution characteristics of OCPs showed that total OCP concentrations were much lower in spring than in summer at six sites including Luanxian, Daheiting reservoir dam, Panjiakou Village, Guojiatun, Qujiawan, and Baichengzi, and were higher in spring than in summer at the remaining eight sites. From the perspective of spatial and temporal variations in the composition patterns of PAHs and OCPs in surface water of the Luanhe River, the low and middle ring species of PAHs were dominant in spring and summer and the proportion of PAHs with different rings showed significant differences. Three-ring PAHs dominated the samples with 51.18% and 67.55% (61.39% on average) of total PAHs in spring, and four-ring and two-ring PAHs accounted for 11.78%-33.94% (20.97% on average) and 13.31%-27.12% (16.94% on average), respectively. In the summer, In the summer, naphthalene(Nap) was the main component of total PAHs at each sampling site and PAHs were predominated by two-ring compounds with 77.08% and 90.62% (83.34% on average) of the total, and by three-ring and four-ring compounds with 7.09%-15.22% (12.40% on average) and 2.23%-7.49% (3.97% on average), respectively. Only the residues of hexachlorocyclohexanes(HCHs) and dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethanes(DDTs) were detected in surface water of the Luanhe River at different degrees and HCHs were the dominant compounds. -HCH was the main pollutant at most sampling sites with 43.78% and 70.09% (56.25% on average) of total HCHs in the spring and with 53.63% and 64.31% (58.37% on average) in the summer. -HCH and -HCH were abundant at other sampling sites. Source analysis based on the isomer ratios indicated that PAHs in the Luanhe River mainly originated from combustion sources and also likely from petroleum processes. Ratios of OCPs confirmed that historical residues and long-range atmospheric transport were the major sources of HCHs in the study area, and new sources of lindane or -HCH existed at Wulongji and Sandaohezi in the spring and Daheting reservoir dam in the summer. Fresh inputs at the Panjiakou reservoir dam, Sandaohezi, Waigoumenzi, Baichengzi, Zhenglanqi, and the Shandianhe reservoir, and environmental residues at Jianggezhuang and Guojiatun were the major sources of DDTs. Concentrations of single PAHs in surface water of the Luanhe River did not exceed the water quality standards of China and other countries except that chrysene(Chr) exceeded the United States national water quality standard. Individual PAHs did not exceed any safety guidelines for aquatic organisms that are exposed to PAHs in water but total concentrations of PAHs exceeded the threshold limits set by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the European Union. This result indicated that consuming fish and other aquatic animals might pose a potential threat to human health due to the bioaccumulation of PAHs in aquatic organisms. The concentrations of OCPs in surface water of the Luanhe River did not exceed any water quality standards or the aquatic life threshold limits for freshwater developed by the EPA. However, the concentrations of -HCH at Jianggezhuang, Wulongji, Qujiawan, and Baichengziand sites in the spring and at the Panjiakou reservoir dam, Panjiakou village, Qujiawan, and Baichengzi sites in the summer, and concentrations of '-DDD at the Shandianhe reservoir and '-DDE at Jianggezhuang, Sandaohezi, Guojiatun, and Shandianhe reservoir in the spring exceeded the human health ambient water quality criteria limit developed by the EPA. This result suggests that -HCH, '-DDE, and '-DDD pose a potential health risk to the residents who live near the sampling sites on the Luanhe River.
2015年春夏季,采用气相色谱 - 串联质谱法(GC/MS/MS)分析了滦河干流14个采样点地表水17种多环芳烃(PAHs)和15种持久性有机氯农药(OCPs)的含量,以阐明其季节分布、组成及潜在来源。结果表明,滦河地表水PAHs总浓度春季为33.33 ng·L至90.65 ng·L(平均52.64 ng·L),夏季为147.68 ng·L至252.68 ng·L(平均169.88 ng·L);OCPs总浓度春季为<0.08 ng·L至3.48 ng·L(平均1.19 ng·L),夏季为<0.08至5.47 ng·L(平均1.02 ng·L)。两个不同季节地表水PAHs的季节污染特征表明,滦河各采样点夏季PAHs总浓度均远高于春季。而OCPs的季节污染特征表明,在滦县、大黑汀水库大坝、潘家口村、郭家沟、屈家店和白城子等6个采样点,OCPs总浓度春季远低于夏季,在其余8个采样点则春季高于夏季。从滦河地表水PAHs和OCPs组成模式时空变化来看,PAHs的低环和中环物种在春夏季占主导,不同环数PAHs比例差异显著。春季三环PAHs占主导,占总PAHs的51.18%和67.55%(平均61.39%),四环和二环PAHs分别占11.78% - 33.94%(平均20.97%)和13.31% - 27.12%(平均16.94%)。夏季,萘(Nap)是各采样点总PAHs的主要成分,PAHs以二环化合物为主,占总量的77.08%和90.62%(平均83.34%),三环和四环化合物分别占7.09% - 15.22%(平均12.40%)和2.23% - 7.49%(平均3.97%)。滦河地表水仅不同程度检出六氯环己烷(HCHs)和滴滴涕(DDTs)残留,且HCHs为优势化合物。α - HCH是多数采样点的主要污染物,春季占总HCHs的43.78%和70.09%(平均56.25%),夏季占53.63%和64.31%(平均58.37%)。β - HCH和γ - HCH在其他采样点含量较高。基于异构体比例的源分析表明,滦河PAHs主要源于燃烧源,也可能源于石油加工过程。OCPs比例证实,历史残留和长距离大气传输是研究区域HCHs主要来源,春季乌龙矶和三道河子、夏季大黑汀水库大坝存在林丹或β - HCH新来源。潘家口水库大坝、三道河子、外沟门子、白城子、正蓝旗和闪电河水库的新输入以及姜各庄和郭家沟的环境残留是DDTs主要来源。滦河地表水单种PAHs浓度除屈蒽(Chr)超过美国国家水质标准外,均未超过中国及其他国家水质标准。单个PAHs未超过水中PAHs暴露的水生生物安全指南,但PAHs总浓度超过美国环境保护局(EPA)和欧盟设定的阈值。这表明由于PAHs在水生生物中的生物累积,食用鱼类和其他水生动物可能对人类健康构成潜在威胁。滦河地表水OCPs浓度未超过任何水质标准或EPA制定的淡水水生生物阈值。然而,春季姜各庄、乌龙矶、屈家店和白城子采样点以及夏季潘家口水库大坝、潘家口村、屈家店和白城子采样点的β - HCH浓度,以及春季闪电河水库的p,p′ - DDD浓度和姜各庄、三道河子、郭家沟和闪电河水库的p,p′ - DDE浓度超过了EPA制定的人类健康环境水质标准限值。这表明β - HCH、p,p′ - DDE和p,p′ - DDD对居住在滦河采样点附近的居民构成潜在健康风险。