Baek Il Hyun, Kim Kyoung Oh, Choi Min Ho, Jung Sung Won, Jang Hyun Joo, Min Kyeong Won
Eulji University Hospital, Eulji University School of Medicine, Daejeon, Korea.
Am Surg. 2018 May 1;84(5):644-651.
Histologic discrepancy may sometimes occur between biopsy and endoscopic resection. We investigated the discrepancy rate between the biopsy and the resection lesion in the Korean population. From January 2010 to October 2016, 268 patients with gastric endoscopic mucosal resection/endoscopic submucosal dissection history from nationwide hospitals were enrolled retrospectively. We compared the histologic discrepancy rates from the biopsy and the resection. The mean age was 63.2 years. Gastric adenomas occurred most frequently in the antrum. The pathology of the resected specimens classified 25 lesions (9.3%) as gastritis/hyperplasia, 146 lesions (54.5%) as low-grade dysplasia, 76 lesions (28.4%) as high-grade dysplasia (HGD), and 21 lesions (7.8%) as adenocarcinoma. The discrepancy rate between biopsy and resection was 23.1 per cent. Among the 44 cases of gastritis/hyperplasia, two cases (4.5%) were diagnosed as HGD and 11 cases (25.0%) were diagnosed as cancer after resection. Among the 182 cases of low-grade dysplasia, 33 cases (18.1%) were diagnosed as HGD and nine cases (5.0%) were diagnosed as cancer after resection. Gastritis/hyperplasia, ulceration, and lesions in the lower body location were significant factors related to the discrepancies. Especially, discrepancy occurred most frequently in gastritis/hyperplasia lesions with ulcer in the lower body. There was considerable histologic discrepancy between biopsy and resection. Ulcerative-type tumor morphology and biopsy diagnosis of gastritis/hyperplasia are suggestive factors predictive of discrepancy between biopsy and resection in terms of malignancy. Therefore, although the results of biopsy are gastritis/hyperplasia, suspicious tumorous lesions with ulcer should be indicative of active endoscopic resection for diagnosis and treatment.
活检与内镜切除之间有时可能会出现组织学差异。我们调查了韩国人群中活检与切除病变之间的差异率。2010年1月至2016年10月,对全国多家医院有胃内镜黏膜切除术/内镜黏膜下剥离术病史的268例患者进行了回顾性研究。我们比较了活检与切除的组织学差异率。平均年龄为63.2岁。胃腺瘤最常发生于胃窦部。切除标本的病理分类显示,25个病变(9.3%)为胃炎/增生,146个病变(54.5%)为低级别上皮内瘤变,76个病变(28.4%)为高级别上皮内瘤变(HGD),21个病变(7.8%)为腺癌。活检与切除之间的差异率为23.1%。在44例胃炎/增生病例中,2例(4.5%)切除后诊断为HGD,11例(25.0%)切除后诊断为癌症。在182例低级别上皮内瘤变病例中,33例(18.1%)切除后诊断为HGD,9例(5.0%)切除后诊断为癌症。胃炎/增生、溃疡以及病变位于胃体下部是与差异相关的重要因素。特别是,胃体下部伴有溃疡的胃炎/增生病变差异最为常见。活检与切除之间存在相当大的组织学差异。溃疡性肿瘤形态以及活检诊断为胃炎/增生是活检与切除在恶性程度方面差异的提示性因素。因此,尽管活检结果为胃炎/增生,但伴有溃疡的可疑肿瘤性病变应积极进行内镜切除以明确诊断和治疗。